Except in that case, you've got an individual winner for something non-work related. Even though everyone participates, people lose, and there's nothing they could do to help that. It's silly, but it could cause bad blood. And... you might think everyone would agree, but have you ever tried to convince a group of people that their current tradition is stupid, and yours is better, even if it is? Your idea is better, but if it were to change, vudu would be wise not to be the one to change it. People react to random stuff like that on a hair-trigger, and it can cause trouble. Even having a vote on what to do could cause some weird passive-aggressiveness in the work place, and it's just not worth the trouble. This isn't a battle I'd pick to fight, because it's just not that big of a deal, and the potential consequences far outweigh the potential benefits.