"I am not one to say graphics are immaterial, however, being convinced not to enjoy a game based upon graphics is a bit superficial. By that I mean, REALLY superficial. If Wind Waker's graphics were hellishly bad, like GTA 3 looking with framerate hanging around 20 fps, you might be a little justified, but Wind Wakers gfx are gorgeous, whether you like them or not. If is as if you went into an art gallery, looked at George Seurat's "A Sunday Afternoon on the Island of La Grande Jatte" and said, "I cannot stand this painting. It is bad," while the painter himself and a mass of art aficianadoes, regular joes, and other esteemed painters in the same field stare at you with a quizzical look,becuase you revealed more about yourself than you did about Seurat's ability as an artist."
I think the example you are trying to use is way off base, you are comparing apples and oranges here, hell you are comparing apples and steam boats. My beef with WW is many things. When I say graphics, I mean more than just the look, I mean the way the look is presented. WW is presented to me like a true animated cartoon, and yes, I cant stand that look. I said it earlier, and was quite clear that cartoons in general have never appealed to me, even as a child. To say they are gorgeous is a matter of opinion and taste, art, food and women can be both ugly or beautiful depending on whos eyes you look at them through. The game itself I found over sipmlified and boring, I honestly for the life dont understand what anyone sees in it, but again, that is their perogitive. As for framerate, it doesnt bother me as much as presentation, I would prefer a solid 60FPS but I can live with a few slowdowns (as long as they are not as bad as True Crime). I loved the atmosphere in MP, the grahics and atmosphere appealed to me, same for ED.
Back to the painting you mention. Again art is one of the most subjective subjects you will ever come accross. What is wrong with someone not liking it even though everyone else does? It just may not suit their eye, they may just not like it. Picasso is an estemed artist, cherished even by some, I think his work is crap. To judge someone based on what they like or dislike in Art, Video or women reveals more about your character then theirs. If we all like the same things we wouldnt need opinions would we?