So is this basically where we explain our reasoning for applauding or smiting people?
I applaud any post that makes me chuckle. BnM is responsible for a lot of those. Crimm gets lots of random applauds. I'll applaud reviewers when I really like their reviews.
Both Mop it up and Thatguy tend to make good posts so I reward them. Also, people that I feel are wrongfully getting over smitten I will applaud to counter the negativity. Like Ratchman.
I smite people usually when I feel they are bringing down a conversation. Not necessarily derailing it, but making me want to start ignoring the thread or something. I've smitten 'Reggie' a lot for that. I don't care if they are right or wrong, it just makes those threads less appealing to me. Spyke also on occasion when I feel he's being a little too nit-picky on technicalities.
I recall both smiting and applauding Pale, Dasmos, Perm, Kytim, Vudu and Lindy but not the reasons why. If someone says something rude to another person I'll smite them.