Okay, here goes.. (I'm sticking to Nintendo consoles..)
Best game that didn't sell:
The GodfatherWorst game that sold too much:
Hanna Montana (DS)Best/Worst handheld game:
BEST -
Phoenix Wright 3: Trials and Tribulations, LoZ: Phantom Hourglass (TIE)Best/Worst console game:
BEST -
Super Mario GalaxyWORST -
Escape from Bug Island (aka Necro-Nesia)
Best 3rd party game <Wii & DS>:
WII -
Zack and WikiDS -
Phoenix Wright: Trials and TribulationsMost HYPED GOTY:
Super Mario GalaxyBiggest Hype but Most Dissapointing GOTY:
Manhunt 2Sleeper Hit of the Year:
Hotel Dusk: Room 215Most Surpising(ly good) GOTY:
The GodfatherBest Action/Adventure game:
Super Mario GalaxyBest Puzzle Game:
Picross DSBest Non-game:
Brain Age 2Best FPS:
Medal of Honour 2 HeroesBest Shmups:
Best Downloadable game:
Super Mario Bros 3Best RPG:
Super Paper MarioBest Online game:
Mario Strikers ChargedOverall GOTY:
SUPER MARIO GALAXYBest gaming gimmick:
Wii remoteWorst gaming gimmick:
Wii remoteBest 2007 game delayed till 2008 or later:
Super Smash Bros BrawlBest/Worst Use of Wii Controls:
BEST -
WarioWare: Smooth MovesBest/Worst Use of DS Touch Controls:
BEST -
LoZ: Phantom HourglassBest/Worst Smash Bros. Dojo Update :
BEST -
Wi-Fi Confirmed, My Music, Stage Builder, OlimarWORST -
Widescreen supportBest Multiplayer Game:
Mario Strikers: ChargedBest Online Game:
Mario Strikers: ChargedForum:
Mod of the year:
TYP, PaleThread of the year:
Guess the PosterPoster of the year:
Best new Poster:
insanolordPoster you wish wasn't banned:
animecyberrat, segagamer12, phatrat1988, rat_born_in_88, RABiclePoster you wish was banned:
Avatar of the year:
BlackNMild's beach sceneSignature of the year:
BlackNMild's 360 sigPost of the year: waay too many
Most quotable poster:
Shecky, zakkiel, Strell, Infernal Monkey, Pro666, vuduPoster that wouldn't stop posting:
Mashiro, pap64, CericBiggest debate of the year: Hmm, this was a relatively tame year..
Third party supportFunniest poster:
Infernal Monkey, StrellMost random poster:
KashogiStogi, Pro666pBiggest/Best Game of mafia:
Best Mafia Host:
Biggest Bump (Hosted by UncleBob?):
My Diddy Kong Pilot one. It's just so damn funny

Forum Member you Love to Hate:
Forum Member you Hate to Love:
Best NWR/Forum event of the Year:
Worst NWR/Forum Event of the Year:
Most down to earth poster:
CericMost smarty poster
Poster that should come back
Image of the year
Image that should be burned
Most missed poster
zakkiel, rat, odifiend, Grey NinjaLeast missed poster
The Hawtest avatar
Ugliest avatar
Site:
Best Editorial:
Best Review:
Most Controversial Editorial:
Most Controversial Review:
Super Swing GolfBiggest Exclusive of the Year:
Biggest News Event of the Year:
Most Surprising News of the Year:
Worst News of the year:
I'm not completely done, but I can't finish right now.