good point odi; that was poor word choice on my part, and I completely forgot about a new 3d mario... jeez thinking about it now gets my pulse racing. I suppose new mario is plenty enough first party love for the launch, but people want online options, and nintendo needs to provide a solid online title at launch to prove that the WiFi connection will treat rev owners as nicely as it does DS fans.
My point is that Casuals who get their info from G4tv will see the cool controller, some wacky japanese micro games and cooking sims, and a new mario and think "hey this is cool".. as opposed to seeing a new SSB game AT LAUNCH and think "omfg i need that, SSB 64 is starting to get old"
(its odd but I know almost half a hundred people who wont play SSb:melee with us around the dorm but stay up till 3am playing the original because it has "more strategy",,, whatever their reasons are, it generally boils down to not being able to keep up with the moving stages or dodge moves)
Anyway, Nitnendo would not be screwing us, for they'd be making a better game, but think about the opportunity cost of spending 3 to 6 months on a game that could propel the rev launch to new heights, a game that could potentially bring back all those morons who left nintendo when they saw Halo. SSB before christmas could lock the rev in for the best christmas present around. college students aren't going to drop $500 for Ps3 setup for the dorm, nor will parents paying tuition fees ... but a $250 Rev setup (system, game) is far more plausible.
If they release SSB 2-3 weeks after the launch, they'll be in good shape. Otherwise that needs to be out on day one.
Funny how I forgot about Mario; I don't know how I'm going to spend my time when the Revolution comes.