We store cookies, you can get more info from our privacy policy.

North America

Harvest Moon: A Wonderful Life

by Jonathan Metts - March 24, 2004, 11:18 pm EST


This is the perfect game to help you train for your date with Paris Hilton.

Harvest Moon isn’t like other games. It’s about farming. That seems like a rudimentary point, but it really seeps into every pore of the gameplay. You can’t approach Harvest Moon expecting anything remotely similar to Final Fantasy, Zelda, or even one of the Sim-(City/World/Ant/s) games. Harvest Moon makes you a farmer, and it makes you like being one. Your days are filled with watering crops, milking cows, and trying to eke out a living in an economic model not exactly rife with profit.

The actual gameplay is extremely simple and repetitive. Depending on how you build your farm, you may be spending a large part of each game day carrying chickens in and out of their coop, or tending to every single plant growing in your fields. For a change of pace, you might try digging in the ruins or going fishing, but these activities are similarly mundane exercises in patience and persistence. The only other significant thing to do in the game is interact with the local townsfolk, which can prove to be a very slow and frustrating process. Most people tell you the same two or three things over and over, so you have to make friends not through conversation, but by handing out gifts until you find something each person is fond of. Then you keep giving that thing until the person finally reciprocates with a little cut-scene or an item which may or may not be worth as much as all the stuff you contributed to the “relationship”.

As with many simulation games, the rewards of playing Harvest Moon are not readily apparent in a brief, isolated game session. It’s the loftier goals, like upgrading your farm or building a family, which make all the intermediate labor seem worth your time. The game is based heavily on the psychology of objectives and self-improvement. Some players are going to respond enthusiastically, others not at all. Although Harvest Moon is quite unique for its subject matter and a few other reasons, it’s safe to say that if you are easily addicted to other simulation games, you will probably have no problem settling into the farm routine.

Much of Harvest Moon’s charm comes from how it presents all the best aspects of farming life. Despite work-filled days and busy walking paths through the village, there is an overriding blanket of serenity to the proceedings. While fishing, you can literally close your eyes, listen to the sound of the rushing water, and drift into a semi-conscious state while casually listening for the “blop!” of a fish on the line. While not technically impressive, the game’s world is painted in soft colors and shadows worthy of any Bob Ross painting. When riding your horse out to the seaside as the sun fades away, it’s hard not to be touched. There are no thrills or explosions in Harvest Moon; this is a game for people who want a break from calamity and wouldn’t mind a peaceful, relaxing experience for once.

There are some downsides to this approach. On many days, especially early in the farm’s life when there is little farmwork and little money to spend on more crops and animals, the game days can stretch on too long. Let’s say you finish watering your single row of watermelons and milk the cow by 10:00 AM on the game clock. That leaves twelve more game hours to amuse yourself or try to make a bit of extra money, and there just aren’t many options for either. The game gets busier as you build up resources and new chores on the farm, but things can be dreadfully slow in the first couple of months, which amount to several real hours of playing.

There are also some unfortunate control problems. The grid-based system used in crop-tending and digging should be simple to use, but the overly sensitive joystick response makes it needlessly difficult to target a particular square. This problem can lead to general frustration when watering plants, as well as some inexcusable accidents, like using the hoe on a nearly-ripe tomato instead of the adjacent plot of untilled soil. Other control problems lie in how certain menus are laid out; selling items to the traveling salesman is ridiculously cumbersome. There are also several unused buttons on the controller that could have made various tasks easier to perform, such as quickly switching from one tool to another. It’s quite mystifying how such a simple game could be riddled with such obvious control faults, though thankfully the game isn’t unplayable from their presence, just annoying at times.

The game also has trouble balancing some of its gameplay elements. For instance, raising crops doesn’t become profitable until you have acquired several new pieces of equipment and a lot of high-quality seeds, which isn’t going to happen in the first ten hours of gameplay. I jumped into planting and harvesting right away, assuming it to be the main part of any good farm, but it didn’t take too long to realize that I was wasting my time raising low-quality seeds and selling the fruit for barely any profit. Then there’s the cooking “mini-game”, which is heavily encouraged by the game but has little practical use, since you can subsist entirely on the free herbs found growing all over the place. Likewise, selling items from your own produce stand in town proves to be slow and ineffective, since most people who come along will want to buy random flowers instead of the crops and dairy that you worked so hard to produce.

Despite these nuisances, Harvest Moon: A Wonderful Life is a pleasant experience that can become frighteningly addictive. There’s nothing quite like the joy of seeing your hen lay a golden egg after months of pampering, and a hundred other little events are similarly fulfilling. This game is so different and surprisingly fun, even to gamers with zero interest in farming, that I feel compelled to recommend at least a rental. If you do get a chance to try Harvest Moon, and you like what you’ve seen, the game is easily long and rich enough to be worth purchasing.


Graphics Sound Control Gameplay Lastability Final
7.5 6 5 8 10 7.5

There are plenty of technical shortfalls, including some very slow, stodgy animations and unimpressive character models. Yet the game has a way of making its simple little world look very pleasing to the eye. Progression of daylight, moonlight, and weather are wholly believable. I like the way your farmer’s feet seem to have less-than-normal friction with the ground as he runs along.


The soundtrack is comprised of simple little songs which fade into the background very naturally. There are only three or four songs in the entire game, and they’re all on short loops, so the music does get old after a while. You can get more songs by connecting to the GBA game, but few players are likely to take advantage of this feature. The sparse sound effects are occasionally funny, but many of them don’t fit very well. The main exception would be the fantastic sound of running water, which will appeal directly to your bladder.


This is a simple game that doesn’t need complex or particularly responsive controls, which is why the failings in this area don’t hurt the game as much as would normally be the case. Rather, you’ll just get slightly ticked off every time you water the wrong square of land, or show a hen to the rooster instead of setting her down, or open the door (which is halfway across the room) instead of pick up an egg right by your feet. It’s all silly stuff that should have been fixed in development long ago.


Aside from some useless mechanics and a general lack of leisure activities, Forget-Me-Not Valley is a great place to live and work. The game starts off pretty slow, but you’ll be addicted before long, and it’s all gravy from there.


You can play for at least ten game years, which translates to dozens hours of actual gameplay. Then your son may take over the farm and keep it going even longer. Few players are likely to ever see the end, that’s for sure, but many will play for weeks and months as they build their farms and families. The game grabs you and won’t let go. There’s a ton of stuff to do, much of it undocumented, so experimentation and exploration pay off. There are also some pretty cool connectivity features with the GBA game, Friends of Mineral Town.


Harvest Moon: A Wonderful Life is a worthy entry to its series and a welcome addition to the GameCube library. Old fans and new players will both find plenty to enjoy in this weird, charming little game. Some relatively minor issues with controls and gameplay keep me from giving my heartiest recommendation, as I have become frustrated and bored at times, but there’s much more good than bad. Definitely give this one a try.


  • Completely different and fresh
  • Incredibly long “adventure”
  • Pleasant, addictive gameplay
  • Annoying control mishaps
  • Some tasks are unproductive
Review Page 2: Conclusion

Share + Bookmark

Genre RPG
Developer Natsume

Worldwide Releases

na: Harvest Moon: A Wonderful Life
Release Mar 16, 2004
jpn: Bokujou Monogatari: Wonderful Life
Release Sep 12, 2003
Got a news tip? Send it in!