Quote
Originally posted by: Ian Sane
"most panned Mario Party 8, and yet somehow is doing smashing, as in twice as well as Mario Party 7, like the consumers are satisfied or something"
What difference does that make? That doesn't make Mario Party 8 a better game than Mario Party 7 or better than any other game. No one here would have DARED suggest that sales mattered when Nintendo was getting royally creamed by Sony. Back then we were all trying to come up with logical excuses as to why Madden always crushed everything in sales while Nintendo's latest awesome game was getting completely ignored.
So your argument is that people on this board shouldn't care about sales because sales were bad during the Cube era? Look the reason sales matter in THIS CONTEXT (happy customers) is that obviously the market disagrees with the reviewers and are quite to very satisfied with the product. and what all of a sudden the Cube had awesome games? Are we forgetting what YOU said about the Cube during its time of release? Are you whitewashing that part of your whining history too?
Quote
"It is simple 'certain' hardcore gamers, some in positions of power, that are dictating this schism as if it was real because they ideologically clash with the results"
There must be something since every time "what do we all think of the Wii" comes up on this forum there is always debate and arguments. At the very least I'd say there's a split among Nintendo fans. They split into two groups: those who like (or tolerate I guess) the direction Nintendo has gone in and those that don't.
There are two groups, but it is not "split" by any stretch. That implies equality in number, which there definitely isn't. There is a non-responder bias on message board complaints threads like this, as usually the content people don't need to jump into forums everyday to remind people of how happy they are. They usually just be happy and content with a product in the real world. Imagine this scenario, the hundreds of thousands of scientists that want to do something about global warming (because it is real) all get into an eco-friendly mag-lev train and the dozens or so of pundits and losers who disagree with the facts (genuinely or otherwise) pile into a custom conversion van with the worst emissions in history. furthermore, they haven't bathed in weeks. The mag-lev train is speeding along, and on the train they are discussing matters of import pertaining to global warming, while the van putters along and pollutes. Just because the people in the van fart the loudest and smell the worst, does not make them an equal group to the scientists because only few or so scientists that deign to argue with them about a reality while the rest are happy to continue their work to stop a global threat.
Oh yeah, I guess you could claim that the DS is the worst Nintendo handheld ever (which you have), and then say the forum is split there too. Split into groups of "Ian Sane" and "People who think Ian Sane is completely batshit bonkers."
Quote
There's no definition of "hardcore" because marketing executives have bullsh!ted the word. Microsoft used "hardcore gamer" as part of the Xbox marketing even though the Xbox was probably the most casual focused of the three consoles. So terms get blurred and end up meaning nothing. Everyone also categorizes games to fit their opinion. You in favour of what Nintendo's doing? Then you're going to try to make as big of a list of "gamer games" you can or you're going to retroactively declare old classic games as non-games to defend non-gaming's worth. Don't like what Nintendo's doing? Then the amount of non-games around is going to be bigger and no game you've ever liked in your life will be a non-game or have anything in common with one.
The topic is about lapsed gamers. Well since there is a split in opinion between Nintendo fans at the very least I can see a group of Nintendo's old fanbase leaving because they don't like what Nintendo's doing.
Once again, two groups does not mean two EQUAL groups. But the reason there is no uniform definition of hardcore is because there isn't one. It changes from person to person and this was true before this whole crap about definition wars between gamers and non-gamers. RPG nuts do not think FPSs are hardcore. People like yourself do not think sports games are hardcore. And yet we hear the opposite from other people. It's just the truth. And now we have protective, defensive flap over how hardcore something is or is not like there are set dimensions where then aren't any.
And the thread doesn't seem to be about "lapsed Wii gamers" but more like "The Wii doesn't have enough <hardcore> games out." Which is a much more common, mundane, tired, old, and groan-inducing statement, but it sounds nice when you gussy it up with Nintendo marketing speak.
Quote
So... you're saying there aren't lapsed gamers... because sales are good? Is this what you're saying? Because while I don't trust Nintendo's PR machine all the time, I'm fairly confident that Nintendo's not making up customers when they say (repeatedly) that they want to attract lapsed gamers.
But apparently there exists this amorphous, phantom-like group of Wii-lapsed gamers made up entirely of the 300 or so people who constantly complain about the Wii on the Entire internet, and their leaving the Nintendo fanfold is a major ripple in the market that is to be felt for generations to come.
There're probably more "Lapsed DS Gamers" than "Lapsed Wii Gamers." Don't hear too much from the first group though.
Quote
Not really. You can substitute "hardcore gamer" with whatever contextually accurate phrase that makes you happy. The point will still be the same. Whoever "they" are, they want less gaps between the games they want to play.
Really?! I can substitute "hardcore gamers" with... say "non-gamers?" Well the non-gamers are pretty happy, I'd imagine. How about "Smash Bros. fans?" They're happy too (they don't have too many "gaps" to fill, basically because they only like Smash Bros.) And what point is this again? That there are Wii-lapsed gamers that can't be defined by any scientific metric but can be "felt" because people whine in the internet? Forgive me if I remain skeptical and continue to play Kirby on my DS.
Edit:
Quote
and to those criticizing the 'whiners'.. shame on u.. lol @ u all of the sudden caring that peter's grandfather played the wii for 3 minutes. lol @ the change of heart towards the main consumers of a system, when it was the ps2 they were dumb drones, now they're the intelligent buyers... these 'whiners' were the 1 who stuck thru da thick and think when the purple lunchbox was one of the worst consoles ever....
....bring it
Have you slung a cog?