We store cookies, you can get more info from our privacy policy.
Wii

North America

Rock Band 2

by Nick DiMola - January 29, 2009, 11:48 am EST
Total comments: 11

9.5

After a rocky start with Rock Band 1, Harmonix has returned to the scene with the definitive band simulation game for Wii.

Last summer, Rock Band made its Nintendo debut. Unfortunately, it was not well-received by critics. A number of concerns were cited, such as its lack of online play and downloadable content, both of which were available on the competing Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 platforms. Thankfully, both items have been addressed by developer Harmonix in this second edition of Rock Band, putting the Wii version on par with its competing versions for the first time.

Indeed, Rock Band 2 on the Wii is as feature-rich as its 360 and PS3 editions. Regardless of the Wii’s supposed hardware limitations, Harmonix has managed to include online band touring, downloadable content with SD card streaming, and all of the other available modes. Having played the Xbox 360 version of the game, I can verify that the only difference between the two lies in their graphical presentation.

The centerpiece of the game is Tour mode, allowing up to four people to perform together either locally or online. Players can perform as a guitarist, bassist, drummer, or vocalists on a large array of songs spanning five decades. During the tour, your virtual band will perform at a variety of clubs, playing either single songs or sets of songs. Unfortunately, as a result, you will be required to play a number of tracks multiple times. As time goes on this becomes frustrating, especially when you are forced to replay songs that aren't of particular interest.

Online play is implemented well on the Wii and works without a hitch. Players can hop into an incomplete band or allow friends or strangers to complete their empty lineup. Because players are immediately connected to the Nintendo WiFi Connection upon loading the game, finding people to play with is quick and easy and requires no traversal of extra menus. Additionally, purchasing and playing extra songs is also simple and works without a hitch. Loading songs from the SD card to play takes roughly the same amount of time as loading from a disc, which is also nice to see.

Progression through the tour will (slowly) unlock all of the available tracks in the game, allowing their use within Quick Play mode, where you will spend most of your time. Rock Band caters to all audiences by allowing players to each choose the appropriate difficulty setting for their instrument of choice, letting amateurs jam with experts. Note charts also never feel over-charted in order to create a false challenge, regardless of the difficulty level at which you’re playing.

One complaint I had with the first Rock Band was a lack of challenging guitar tracks, and Rock Band 2 undoubtedly addresses this issue. With selections like Metallica's "Battery," Dream Theater's "Panic Attack," and Megadeth's "Peace Sells," Rock Band 2 offers some of the most demanding guitar riffs of the series.

Aside from the main tour and quick play modes of the game, players have access to a variety of other modes such as band duels, practice mode, and even a drum trainer mode allowing players to learn basic drum beats and fills or just mess around with a variety of kits.

Players with HDTVs will find calibration to be a breeze in Rock Band 2 thanks to the brand new equipment supplied in the full band package. The included guitar allows players to auto-sync by simply holding the guitar approximately three feet from the television. No longer will players need to perform the tedious test found in prior editions of the game, or tweak the calibration to achieve that perfect synchronization.

On a similar note, the included peripherals are an excellent upgrade from the prior version of the game. Both the guitar and drum set are wireless, and easily connect to the Wii through the wireless USB adapter set included in the package. The drum kit now features pad silencers built right into each of the pads, as well an overhauled, sturdier kick pedal. Additionally, three expansion ports have been included in order to accommodate the cymbal expansion provided by MadCatz, which was developed to give the kit a more authentic feel.

With its large number of modes, weekly DLC that is accessible via the SD Card, online play, better instruments, a variety of modes, diverse soundtrack, and excellently charted songs, Rock Band 2 is the definitive band game for Wii. Anyone with Rock Band 1 instruments should pick this one up without question, and those who have yet to invest should consider Rock Band 2 before any other band game currently on the market.

Score

Graphics Sound Control Gameplay Lastability Final
6 10 10 9 10 9.5
Graphics
6

I can't definitively say if Rock Band 2 is a port of the PS2 version, but it sure looks like it is. There’s great animation during songs and flawless presentation through all of the menus and modes, but the game simply looks terribly low-res and low-poly.

Sound
10

The sound quality is fantastic and has no obvious flaws. The song selection is varied and interesting, giving the game broad appeal. All of the included songs are also master tracks, not remakes done by the internal Harmonix musicians.

Control
10

Unlike the prior edition of the game and its associated track packs, calibration is a cinch. The included instruments are excellently constructed, and the game plays flawlessly when everything is properly set up.

Gameplay
9

It's hard to conceive Rock Band 2 playing much better for what it is. The difficulty ramps up nicely, the included tracks are eclectic, and the game provides countless modes to enjoy in addition to the main Tour mode. The only aggravation is the necessity of constantly replaying the same songs in the touring mode in order to complete the game.

Lastability
10

With 84 songs available on the disc, 20 for free download, and new content available weekly, players could conceivably play this game into perpetuity.

Final
9.5

Rock Band 2 is the definitive band game experience on Wii. Players who own band equipment should not wait a moment to add this game to their collection. Others looking to invest should buy Rock Band 2 with its full peripheral set, as the provided instruments are wireless and fantastically crafted.

Summary

Pros
  • Drum Trainer Mode
  • Excellent Equipment
  • Online play is well done
  • (Streaming) DLC
  • Varied track list
Cons
  • Replaying songs in the tour mode becomes tedious
Review Page 2: Conclusion

Talkback

MorariJanuary 29, 2009

No mention of cross compatibility with Guitar Hero's instruments? That's the only reason I even picked up the game, as I already had a set of instruments from Guitar Hero: World Tour. To be fair however, I do think that I like Rock Band 2 better overall. That's not to say that World Tour is lacking in things that I think Rock Band would benefit from... Rock Band 2 just seems to have an overall better feel to it, and certainly has a better setlist out of the box, despite several hugely awesome tracks that are seemingly exclusive to World Tour.

Nick DiMolaNick DiMola, Staff AlumnusJanuary 29, 2009

Quote from: Morari

No mention of cross compatibility with Guitar Hero's instruments?

I don't have the instruments, so I really can't say much about it. Personally not a fan of World Tour, so I never bought it.

Quote from: Morari

No mention of cross compatibility with Guitar Hero's instruments? That's the only reason I even picked up the game, as I already had a set of instruments from Guitar Hero: World Tour.

It's funny, that never even crossed my mind while editing this.  I'm a Rock Band guy myself (I've never played GH, ever), and I bet Nick would say the same.

MorariJanuary 30, 2009

Well, I can assume that instrument compatibility is a pretty big deal to many people. I've never used the Rock Band instruments simply because the first game was not worth purchasing on the Wii due to cut features. That said, the Guitar Hero peripherals (from both Legends of Rock and World Tour) seem to work just fine in Rock Band 2. The drums have an extra, seemingly unused cymbal. The guitars have no way of tap-strumming the solo sections. And in the case of the World Tour guitar, it's touch sensitive area is not recognized. It is my understanding that the Rock Band instruments do not work within Guitar Hero at all. So if you want to be able to play both series without investing a lot in fake guitars, you're best off with the World Tour set.

Nick DiMolaNick DiMola, Staff AlumnusJanuary 30, 2009

The Rock Band instruments will work in GH:WT, though the drums will be simplified to compensate for the missing fifth button.

Also I can't say of always been a Rock band guy, as I have played and love GH 1 and 2; however, I am a Harmonix guy :P

SpinnzillaJanuary 30, 2009

Personally I enjoy GHWT more, mainly for the exclusive tracks and I like the overall gameplay better.  But I've played rock band and it does feel more well put together. 

I think rock band has the edge co-op wise, but solo and competitive wise I think guitar hero does it better. 

MorariJanuary 30, 2009

Quote from: Mr.

The Rock Band instruments will work in GH:WT, though the drums will be simplified to compensate for the missing fifth button.

I knew that this was the case on other platforms, but didn't realize it to be true for the Wii as well.

Nick DiMolaNick DiMola, Staff AlumnusJanuary 30, 2009

Quote from: Morari

Quote from: Mr.

The Rock Band instruments will work in GH:WT, though the drums will be simplified to compensate for the missing fifth button.

I knew that this was the case on other platforms, but didn't realize it to be true for the Wii as well.

Ah, it appears you're right, only the microphone will work with GH:WT Wii, though the GH:WT instruments will work with RB2.

MorariJanuary 30, 2009

And you call yourself a reviewer! :P

EasyCureFebruary 01, 2009

I picked this game up, finally, and after playing for only an hour or so (solo mind you) i can say... eh.. i like GH:WT better so far. Maybe once i have people over and bust this out, the co-op everyone raves about might change my opinion, but until then i really prefer GH and will continue to (stubbornly) play thru this just to get to some of the exclusive songs found here and not in World Tour.

vuduFebruary 02, 2009

Quote from: Mr.

Personally not a fan of World Tour, so I never bought it.

But ... but ... TOOL

Share + Bookmark





Rock Band 2 Box Art

Genre Rhythm
Developer Harmonix
Players1 - 4
Online1 - 4

Worldwide Releases

na: Rock Band 2
Release Dec 22, 2008
PublisherElectronic Arts
RatingTeen

Related Content

Got a news tip? Send it in!
Advertisement
Advertisement