Heh, I guess I am an odd ball, I'm atheist and loved signs.
Top ten movies
1) Pi
2) Armagedon Now
3) Full Metal Jacket
4) Dogma
5) The Lord of The Rings: The Two Towers
6) Sleepless in Seattle
7) Requiem for a Dream

We Were Soldiers
9) Silence of the Lambs
10) Signs
Hey, I like Evolution, its stupid as hell, but I still am entertained by it.
Whether or not you like Signs, thats up to you, but even if I don't like the idea of fate, I still think it is a powerful tool for all people to think about. I mean, the only way you can appreciate a lot of things is if you just let go, and try to understand the directors thoughts. That was the only way I learned to enjoy Romeo and Juliet, or to like some chick flicks, is because you just have to let your guard down. If you come into a movie thinking 'it has to go with what I think', 99 out of 100 times you will be let down. It's the same with video games, you play and try not to make the game into something it isn't, you play to play the game and let it identify itself, then decide whether you like it.
There are a lot of cheaply not very well produced movies that are classics. Pi probablly could have been done much better, but it still shines as a work to me, just because of it's underlying themes.