Based on gameplay alone Def Jam Vendetta is an absolute blast to play and is probably the best 3D wrestling game ever. However it's really weak when it comes to features. There are very few match types and you can't even do a computer vs computer battle. Worst of all there NO Create-A-Wrestler feature. My opinion is that it's inexcusable for a this game to have less features than Aki's N64 wrestling games so I'll never buy it. It's a great rental though. If a sequel featured more match types and features that, you know, games from like FOUR YEARS AGO were expected to have I would buy it.
The lack of a CAW really boggles my mind though. In a game full of rappers and other non-wrestling related characters wouldn't it make the MOST sense to allow people to create their own wrestlers? Why turn off wrestling fans who don't like rap?