So I don't have a PC to run Athena's charm finder thing but I understand how to get figures for it so now let's see here... I assume sending all 3 ships won't matter so I'm gonna do that and get some results for someone nice to feed into the thing.
now all 3 ships are headed for moga coast with no tackle. Let's hope for the best here I guess.
Update:
Ship1 (Got them all nice and organized):
shining starfish x1, shining starfish x1, popfish x5, pin tuna x2
Ship2 (Ship 1.5)
shining starfish x2, popfish x5, pin tuna x2 shining starfish x1
Ship 3 (she sells seashells by the seashore)
shining starfish x1, popfish x5, sushifish x3, sushifish x3, Humspun Conch x4