I fail to see what the ruckus is about - was anyone blown away by anything at E3 for any platform? The only announcement with far-reaching implication may be a Sony handheld, but we've expected that for quite a while and it was a natural - heck every cell phone company has a "handheld." N wasn't going to continue the 15 yr stranglehold for much longer.
Honestly, it looks like N had some really nice exclusives and first/second party stuff. What was expected, here? I'm fairly certain there will be 5-10 GC games that will prove to be yards better than 99% of anything on other consoles. The systems are 2-3 years old now and nobody is likely to be "staggered" by anything. As much as I dislike Microsoft, I will admit knowing Halo2, Half-Life2 and Doom 3 will be in the offing (although we've known that for ages) will probably lead me to purchase the Box, but those games are BEHEMOTHS and exceptions to the rule - GC is far deeper in existing and upcoming quality than either of the other systems.
We naturally dissect everything Nintendo does. I would have loved to see the alleged Mario 128 - but if its wasn't ready to show, I understand. If it looked half-finished, there'd be a thousand whiners on this board about it. I've heard it about Metroid, Wind Waker, Wario World and now I hear it about Starfox. We know how the first two came out, I'm reasonably sure Wario will be a kick in the ass, and when the boys finish polishing Starfox to a spit-shine, we will have another top-drawer title.
Relax, Francis...