Yeah, we are being totally harsh on him, but I think that we are all sick of hearing that question. A game's worth is not determined by its rating, but by its content.
I didn't even look twice at Smuggler's Run, I played GTA3 based on all the hype, and I hate it. I haven't even bothered trying Dead to Rights or Red Faction 2 yet, and the list goes on and on.
On the other hand, I love Splinter Cell, Zelda: Wind Waker, Mario Sunshine, Eternal Darkness, Resident Evil, Rogue Leader, Animal Crossing, and Pikmin.
What does this say?