The Cave Story TalkBack thread didn't seem like a good place to discuss this so I'm bringing the conversation over here.
Keep in mind that March 22 is still a month away. We're not going to be talking about Blaster Master for THAT long.
Mega Man 10 will be in between those two games.
Are you guys planning on doing Game Club every episode?
To be perfectly honest, I prefer Newscast to be short and sweet. It seems like you're adding Game Club to get some audience participation and beef up the podcast. I don't think it needs any of this. Personally, I'd much prefer a short 45 minute to an hour podcast summing up the news/releases/etc.
Plus, since you're discussing new games in the segment some people might not want to hear about them right away. Especially with games like Blaster Master and Cave Story which rely so heavily on exploration and discovery. I'll admit you did a good job of avoiding spoilers on this episode, but what about the next? You'll be farther into the game and if will hamper discussion if you can't talk in detail about some stuff that I'd frankly rather not hear at this point (I will play the game but I have no plans to in the next few weeks). Am I supposed to keep the podcast on my iPod for the next several months until I beat the game? RFN doesn't really have this problem with RetroActive since it centers around old games.
There's no reason why Game Club needs to be a part of Newscast. My guess is it's just tacked onto the end of the episode because the three of you were already recording. Since you're asking for reader/listener participation I think it would work better if there was just one thread/news story that included everything--posts, thoughts, short stand-alone podcasts, etc. rather than have a discussion thread and then spread the audio over a couple different podcasts.
Those are just my thoughts. Do whatever you like--as I'm sure you will!