I'm still very much on the fence about Silent Hill BECAUSE I like the core mythos so much. SH2 and SH3 are among my favorite horror games, each for different reasons (they're very different games). That said, the series got stale very quickly after that. It's definately time to retool, and I actually like the way Shattered Memories is doing it, but did they really need to reboot the core mythos?
I eagerly await Andy's review. It's a shame you didn't get to talk about your favorite WiiWare games, Jonny. I, for one, would appreciate it if you could list them here, as I'm in the market for a WiiWare game (up to $10).