I finished The Hard Times of RJ Berger this weekend. It was okay, had some decent jokes. It took most of the 1st season to get going. I feel like the writers/showrunners started to get more comfortable when they stopped trying so hard to be this hip show (self-aware because it's about an outcast) pandering to horny teenagers who can see half-naked chicks online (which they never stopped doing entirely, just focused on it less) and started thinking about how to make the characters more likable, interesting, and well-rounded. The show borrows a lot from far more interesting shows/movies like Freaks and Geeks (RJ's dream girl ends up being a less than ideal match. It's a shame that MTV cancelled the series when they did because it was starting to hit its stride and I thought season 3 had potential.
The show is definitely flawed. It's filled with cliches and some rather cheap attempts at humor (RJ has a ridiculously large penis). It exists as a teen show rather than a show about teens (I know they're movies, but think American Pie vs Ghost World). I think that's where it suffers the most. It sometimes tries to aspire for more yet refuses to commit to it. Despite giving some characters depth, others (namely RJ's best friend, Miles) remain woefully one-dimensional. RJ trades one manic pixie dream girl for another manic pixie dream girl who tries so hard not to be one (but, unfortunately, never breaks the mold), meaning he never really learns anything, at least not during the show's run. Maybe that's a meta-concept where RJ has to reject the MPDG in order to learn anything of value, but I highly doubt the writers were that clever. I guess we'll never really know.
It won't win any awards for originality or anything in general and it will likely be forgotten in the annals of television history, but I actually didn't mind it.