This may seem like a slight de-rail, but how strong are your consumer laws over there in the US? I find the laws here in NZ regarding that pretty good and that is me speaking from both sides of the fence (Ex-Retail). Here, it is a basic understanding that anything must last at least a year or more. It don't matter what the warranty period is on the box, it is at least a year. Also from what I have gathered so far, 360's seems to the be the only item ever that you can't go directly through the retailer to get fixed. You always seemed to be bounced off to a MS number. Everything else is, bring it in, test, check receipt, exchange for new one off the shelve. Shop RMA's the sucker back for credit. I don't know what happens to the item, but I think most are destroyed or autopsied. I have never seen a "new" item that is actually refurbished. Besides, if an item wasn't new was being sold as new, well, crap hits the fan.