BUMP!
Sorry to bump up such an old thread but I finally played the game and wanted to put my two cents in.
I liked the game, but to be honest it wasn't THAT fantastic. I personally disagree when people say "The reason some fans are glorifying some Wii games is because they are hungry and starved for games", but I can't help but agree with the sentiment when discussing Super Paper Mario.
First, the story was cute, charming and had plenty of excellent humor. But it isn't enough to keep me playing. Its true that you don't play Mario games for the story, but considering there is a lot of it in this game I thought they would've made it more interesting, specially near the end.
Second, the stages themselves are rather bland and kinda boring. There are some winners, but overall I wasn't truly enjoying playing through these stages. Some of them were downright annoying, though. When will developers learn the difference between challenging your players and annoying them? That space level irritated the crap out of me...
I honestly don't understand why they didn't make it so that all characters could switch to 3D. Even if it just takes seconds you will be changing characters and Pixls a lot and it can get it grating.
Some of the features, special power ups, items and attacks were kinda cute but gimmicky.
Overall, I give the game an 8. I recommend trying it out since it is a good game. I just don't see this as the very special game many made it out to be. Hell, I had a lot more fun playing Wii Play!