Well, in that case, with my plan, one of the townies would be killed over night, still leaving the vote 2 mafia and 4 townies. The next day, again, Pale could reveal the last of the Kaplan Krew and the four townies would kill him off.
Then, overnight, we'd all be wondering who the last Reggie Mafia member is as they strike out and kill a townie (it wouldn't really help the Reggie Mafia to kill off Pale, so he might live through the end afterall). The next day, we'd all have a 1 in 2 chance of voting for the mafia. It could be interesting.