I got to play the Arcade version of Soul Calibur II, and I think it lives up to the glory of Soul Calibur I perfectly. I never owned a Dreamcast, but I played the DC Soul Calibur with friends, and I played Soul Calibur I in the arcade occasionally, so I have some basis for comparison. From my arcade experience with Soul Calibur II, I believe it will appease old fans perfectly; I dare say it is better than Soul Calibur I.