Quote
Originally posted by: Caliban
IGN Insider had a head-to-head between Bioshock and Prime 3 and Bioshock won...
For no good reason apparently, but then again this was the opinion of just one lame person, Nate Ahearn.
I would post the whole article here but I don't know if the NWR rules allow me too.
OMG, I Just read the head to head comparison, talk about comparing apples to radishes. There is no way BIoshock has better art style than Metroid Prime 3, the characters in MP3 have such an out of this world, unique look to them. Bioshocks character design is good, but it isn't what you would call super original.
Unique world? What? Bioshock's world is very familiar, it may be creative, but still it is quite familiar to our own, just darker. Metroid Prime 3 on the other hand has some very diverse landscapes, with visual touches to them that differentiate them from ANYTHING out there.
Immersion. While Bioshock has an engaging world, it isn't quite like having the Wiimote in your hand and interacting with the enviroment around you. Metroid Prime 3 may not have all the snazzy special effects but you feel like you are samus, heck you've felt like that since the first game, that form of immersion is tough to top especially since it is virtually like you are looking through her eyes.
Pushing the genre forward. Do I even need to comment on this? Metroid Prime 1-3 never were built around pushing the genre forward, instead they created a NEW genre, one that has yet to be replicated well. Bioshock, while a great, well polished game, still doesn't have much to differentiate it, gameplay wise from other shooters. Yeah it has slick visuals, neat moral choices, and psychological, heart pumping gameplay, but compared to Metroid Prime 3 (WHich as stated earlier I do not like doing but this guy at IGN forced me too!) it is super shallow, whether it be puzzles, diversity, boss fights, strategy, and art design.