Thanks to TYP for keeping score.
Game 1: Sonic Adventure 2: Battle (GC)
Points to: FFantasyFX, MarioLinkSamus, Vincent_de_Boule, TheViper, Kenny_Blankenship, Joshums, Rimmer, Kentop, Chiphead, Br26, NikJam, TKnHappyNess
Q: What was the first four-player Sonic game released in the U.S.?
<NikJam> sonic shuffle
Game 2: Castlevania 2: Simon's Quest (NES)
Points to: Joshums, MarioLinkSamus, TheViper, ulanshad, nellyp, FFantasyFX, Vincent_de_Broule, Kenny_Blankenship, TheYoungerPlumber
Q: Which special weapon bounces all over the screen?
<Vincent_de_Boule> Diamond
Game 3: Actraiser 2 (SNES)
Points to: TheViper, Kenny_Blankenship, Vincent_de_Boule
Q: Which level is associated with Envy?
<Sir_Pinch-a-Loaf> tower of souls
-----HALFTIME-----
Phish - "Love You" (Syd Barrett cover, including vacuum cleaner solo)
Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon - "I am Impact!" (Arranged version)
-----HALFTIME-----
Game 4: Darkwing Duck (NES)
Points to: Mikemn, TheViper, Kenny_Blankenship, Vincent_de_Boule, Br26, NikJam, Chiphead, TheYoungerPlumber
Q: Which main character did the Darkwing Duck series share with Duck Tales?
<Kenny_Blankenship> Launchpad
Game 5: Donkey Kong 64
Points to: Mikemn, NikJam, Chiphead, TheYoungerPlumber
Q: What were the only two N64 games that completely required the Expansion Pak?
<Sir_Pinch-a-Loaf> majora's mask, dk64
Tiebreaker: Kenny_Blankenship vs. Vincent_de_Boule
Tiebreaker 1: Demon's Crest (SNES)
(Both guesses correct)
Tiebreaker 2: Brain Lord (SNES)
(Neither guess correct)
Tiebreaker 3: <Kenny_Blankenship> Beavis & Butthead
-----FINAL RESULTS-----
Kenny_Blankenship: 5 + Tiebreaker
Vincent_de_Boule: 5
TheViper: 4
NikJam: 4
TheYoungerPlumber: 3
Chiphead: 3
FFantasyFX: 2
MarioLinkSamus: 2
Mikemn: 2
Joshums: 2
Sir_Pinch-a-Loaf: 2
Br26: 2
Rimmer: 1
Kentop : 1
TKnHappyNess: 1
Ulanshad: 1
Nellyp: 1