Author Topic: R.I.P. BioWare: A Studio Rarely Seen on Nintendo Consoles  (Read 5535 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Evan_B

  • Running on Mt. Must Dash
  • Score: 7
    • View Profile
R.I.P. BioWare: A Studio Rarely Seen on Nintendo Consoles
« on: October 21, 2026, 09:10:57 PM »
Yeah, uh.

It’s sad to see a studio so beloved finally close its doors, even if I can’t speak to having rich experiences with any of its games. The only BioWare game I ever played was Mass Effect 3 as part of a podcast dare, and that experience was as miserable as playing Trails in the Sky 3 sans context, except it took itself a bit more seriously. I have no doubt that EA will do everything it it’s power to exploit the intellectual property of the studio with as low a bar for quality and inversely high a bar for profit as they can, but I don’t want to imagine that future. Rather, I can think of no better way to celebrate the storied catalogue of titles of this studio than by hearing your thoughts and feelings on their games. If you reply to this thread, it’s because I actually value your perspective. Not to say I don’t value the opinion pieces written by other games journalists. Their livelihood is reliant on taking about how these corporate morons mismanage their assets. But from what I understand, even from the short time I’ve had with their games, is that people connect to the choices and stories that BioWare’s games offer. Especially the Sonic RPG.

I will add my thoughts at some point, but yeah. The industry sucks ass at the moment, though EA’s tradition of closing down beloved game studios is evidence that it has happened before and likely will happen again.
Will Evan_B ever create something worth appreciating? Stick around and find out!

Offline broodwars

  • Hunting for a Pineapple Salad
  • Score: -1010
    • View Profile
Re: R.I.P. BioWare: A Studio Rarely Seen on Nintendo Consoles
« Reply #1 on: October 21, 2026, 10:13:01 PM »
I can't say I held any love for modern Bioware, not after having actually played the disasters that are Anthem and Mass Effect Andromeda (though I will note that the Mass Effect Andromeda books are reasonably entertaining for what they are).

That said, I've enjoyed a lot of past Bioware games. I believe my first game of theirs was the original Knights of the Old Republic, back when I still played PC games (hey, my username had to come from somewhere). That game's writing really captured the wonder of the Star Wars universe, and while Bioware didn't make the sequel that was only compounded in KOTR 2 when I saw locations and characters I'd only heard of in the Star Wars Expanded Universe comics/audio dramas.

Never got around to playing Jade Empire, though I do own it on my Xbox One. Like most, though, my heart from that time belonged to the original Mass Effect, where I got to see them do for Star Trek what they had already done with Star Wars. It may seem a silly thing, but the thing that told me that ME would truly be for me? The first time I unlocked a Codex entry, opened it up expecting to see another ream of text I'd barely skim and forget in 5 seconds, and instead being treated to a fully-voiced data log explaining a fascinating aspect of the game's universe. It's that level of craftsmanship, that attention to detail, that really sold me on Bioware.

Before too long, I'd read all the books (aside from the one that was recalled due to being written by a fraud), and I was even working at EA when both Dragon Age 2 and Mass Effect 2 released. DA 2 rightfully gets a lot of **** for all the corners cut in its development, all the recycling of dungeons, and the extremely limited play space. However, I found the writing as strong as ever, and it's still the only game in the series I've managed to get through (I bounced off the 1st DA HARD, as I like to play as a mage and the mage's origin both looks and plays like ass). It also allowed me the rare flexibility to play as both a hero and a total smart ass. So many RPGs are so incredibly serious all time. It's also the rare RPG where you get to see a central location change over a long period of time as you build and grow relationships with a small cast of characters that have their own lives beyond you.

As much as I loved the original Mass Effect, for all its faults, Mass Effect 2 was the one that really got its hooks in me. While it was a shame to lose the total freedom of exploration the 1st game had, ME 2 just plays so much better, and I found the game's strong emphasis on character-specific quests very rewarding. It reminded me of how Majora's Mask based everything on building personal connections through small personal stories.

Unfortunately, then Mass Effect 3 happened, and while I won't call the game a total travesty (like many would) it was still such a profound disappointment. So much build-up across 2 games and 3 books ("4, sir!" "Shut up!") for so little payoff. I've always heard the DLC redeems that game somewhat, but those came out long after I was done with that game, and considering how that game ends I just couldn't find the desire to roll back the clock for more adventures before The End. I would have enjoyed doing them as I did my original playthrough. It's pretty much why I can't get behind all the stuff Nintendo's adding to the Xenoblade Switch 2 versions. Yeah, all that stuff sounds cool, but I did my time with those games. The emotional investment is gone, and I have little interest in starting fresh again.

Also...

Where are my Krogans riding genetically-engineered Dinosaurs in the final battle cutscenes, Bioware?! YOU PROMISED ME KROGANS RIDING INTO WAR ON GENETICALLY-ENGINEER DINOSAURS!

*ahem*

Nothing Bioware made after that really interested me. Yeah, I picked up Dragon Age Inquisition: GOTY edition. It's there on my shelf to get to...some day, but I have to say all the years of "GET OUT OF THE HINTERLANDS" kind of dampened my desire to ever start that game. Then Andromeda came out and was just awful. They took a focused narrative experience with the original ME trilogy, and they followed it up with Open World bloat featuring characters I just couldn't care about. Played the game for a few nights and then just gave up on it, but like I said...the 3 books set around it are pretty OK if you're into that sort of thing.

Tried Anthem earlier this year to see if I wanted to try to hunt the Plat before the servers got shut down. After 2 missions, I knew I never wanted to see that game ever again.

Setting aside the negative reception of Dragon Age: The Veilguard at launch, I couldn't muster up interest in it because I never got around to playing the game that set it up: Inquisition.

Overall, I'll miss the Bioware that reignited my twin loves for Star Trek and Star Wars in the 2000s when both were going through a rough patch. One day, I hope to do a critical reappraisal of the Mass Effect Trilogy through that copy of Legendary Edition sitting on my shelf. That said, it's been no secret that the studio has been hemorrhaging talent for years, most notably to Archetype Entertainment and its upcoming Mass Effect spiritual successor, Exodus. The studio's last 3 major projects have all been high-profile bombs. They haven't had a hit since Inquisition in 2014, and to be frank that year was full of so many AAA disasters (Destiny 1, Assassin's Creed Unity, Watch_Dogs) that its only serious competition for GOTY was a mediocre Assassin's Creed/Batman knockoff (LOTR:Shadow of Mordor).

I hope that the people still at Bioware that had the talent and the passion find gainful employment elsewhere, but I won't miss what Bioware became in its later years. Sure, you can blame EA's idiotic engine and service model mandates for a lot of it, but Bioware's historic strength was its writing and from all accounts the writing in Veilguard was considered poor, and I can personally attest that Andromeda's and Anthem's were awful from what I saw. I can't say I'd want to see another poorly-written Mass Effect game after Andromeda.
« Last Edit: October 21, 2026, 10:48:59 PM by broodwars »
There was a Signature here. It's gone now.

Offline Evan_B

  • Running on Mt. Must Dash
  • Score: 7
    • View Profile
Re: R.I.P. BioWare: A Studio Rarely Seen on Nintendo Consoles
« Reply #2 on: October 22, 2026, 02:02:21 PM »
Damn, I did not make the connection that Shadow of Mordor released the same year as all those other bombs. Helps put the “Game of the Year” moniker into context, as I’ve already said my piece on the overall vibe and mechanics of that game.

Again, I will post about my slight experience with BioWare titles later. I’m also fascinated to see the perspectives of others who have really enjoyed their games… or bounced off some of their later releases. I have heard tales of Anthem’s mediocrity but I never saw enough of it to quite understand why.
Will Evan_B ever create something worth appreciating? Stick around and find out!

Offline M.K.Ultra

  • is late to the party
  • *
  • Score: 17
    • View Profile
    • Games I'm Playing
Re: R.I.P. BioWare: A Studio Rarely Seen on Nintendo Consoles
« Reply #3 on: October 23, 2026, 11:39:41 AM »
The only BioWare game I have played is the aforementioned Mass Effect 3, which I only picked up because it was on Wii U. With nothing to compare it against I had a good time and really enjoyed the game. I do have a copy of the newest Dragon Age game on PS5 but have not played it yet. With the transfer of EA this did not really come as a surprise but still a sad moment for longtime fans.

Offline Khushrenada

  • is an Untrustworthy Liar
  • NWR Junior Ranger
  • Score: 40
    • View Profile
Re: R.I.P. BioWare: A Studio Rarely Seen on Nintendo Consoles
« Reply #4 on: November 09, 2026, 03:17:08 AM »
First, congrats to Evan_B. When he first posted this thread, it was how I first learned that BioWare had been shuttered that day. Looks like these forums are still a timely way to get current events.

Second, on doing some reflecting, it made me realize how much I'd forgotten about BioWare in the last decade.

For me, BioWare first grabbed my attention with Knights of the Old Republic. The first XBox will forever be associated with Halo and Halo 2 as the sort of identity of that system and the games most likely to be named in its library. Those titles and the image of XBox as being a big home for FPS games did not interest me or make me want to purchase a console. PS2, on the other hand, had things like Sly Cooper, Ratchet & Clank and other platformers and intriguing RPGs like FFX or XenoSaga. But with Knights of the Old Republic, that was the biggest title in the XBox library that could have swayed me into possibly getting the console and was probably the one title I wish I could have ported over to the GC if I had the power. I actually thought BioWare was a first party developer for Microsoft at the time and thereafter for awhile since that was the first I'd heard about them and that game and its sequel stayed exclusive to XBox to give me that impression. It's only when looking up and doing some research on BioWare after this news was announced that I found out they weren't even the ones who made KotOR 2. Obsidian Entertainment did that. News to me.

The other thing that was surprising about BioWare when KotOR came out was to learn that they were a Canadian company based in Edmonton. It's a place I'm more familiar with and not one I would normally associate with being a location to have a kind of high profile gaming studio and one that could be given the Star Wars license to make a hit RPG with.

In the Wii years and latter half of the double-0 decade, my gaming time and interest went into a decline and I wasn't following things as closely. When Mass Effect came out, I knew it was a big deal for the 360 and PS3 and was a popular title for those systems but I just knew it as a space RPG but it was something I'd forget when sometimes naming popular releases for those systems. When Sonic Chronicles was suddenly announced, that really piqued my interest and seemed like it could be a big opportunity for the Sonic franchise to get out of the low it was kind of going through at that time. When Mario was put into an RPG for the first time on the SNES and Nintendo partnered with Square, it created a real unique gem for the SNES and led to the path of both the Paper Mario and Mario & Luigi series. People had been complaining about all the growing number of side characters in Sonic games but an RPG could be a better way to make use of them. Having still not played a BioWare game at that point, I just knew they were pretty well regarded as a developer of great and well-received RPGs at that point in time and it was more based on how appealing the KotOR series and games had seemed to me that made me rather excited for this title. Especially since it would be coming exclusively to the DS. (As a little side note, Sonic Chronicles was actually the prize for a Mafia game themed around Sonic. NickMitch ended up being the one to win that prize).

I did get around to buying Sonic Chronicles but still have never played it to this day. The reception after it released seemed to be disappointment and it really killed my enthusiasm for the game. I still thought I'd play it as my opinion may not match what others were saying but with so many other RPGs to play, it just hasn't happened. (Second side note: The game later got wrapped up in Ken Penders legal battle with Archie Comics after they let him go from writing the Sonic comic series and who actually owned the characters he created for that series. The Dark Brotherhood was seen as coping the villainous Dark Legion he'd created for the Knuckles spin-off and so he sued BioWare for copyright infringement as well. I seem to recall BioWare stating that Sega told them they had the rights to all the characters created in the Archie Comic series and thus admitting they had taken some inspiration from the comic books when making the game but I could be misremembering at this point. In any case, it was the cherry on top to fully mark and view the game as a failure after the game already sold below expectations and the plans to make it a series had been scrapped.) I still think it's kind of a missed opportunity that Sega has never tried to make another Sonic RPG since.

As I did start to get back into gaming in 2010 and 2011, that was also around the time that Mass Effect 2 had been released and that was the title that broke through in my ignorance of the series at that point as I began to actually learn more about the characters in it and what the story was in it and the first game. It seemed to get more discussion that I was reading and aware of than when the first game came out. It all sounded rather interesting but not something I felt terribly compelled to play or would want to purchase another system for. I remember Star Wars: The Old Republic launching for PC as a MMORPG and some of the hype happening for that. Again, that sort of piqued my interest more than Mass Effect but not as much as the original KotOR games. I'm trying to think if I've ever played any MMORPG before and I just can't think of ever doing so. To me, those games just seemed so undefined with no real goal or purpose. Probably why it took me so long to finally try and play an Animal Crossing game.

Even though, BioWare was releasing some other stuff in this time period (I vaguely recall seeing the Jade Empire box art for awhile when working in retail,) these were the only games that I was actually aware of and in which I knew they were the ones to make (or thought they had with KotOR2). Mass Effect 3 came out and that was seen as a big deal as it was hyped as the conclusion of the Mass Effect trilogy. I do remember talk of the ending and that people felt 2 was the better game as discussions began on it after it came out and the news of BioWare doing something to change the ending later. But I mainly remember Mass Effect 3 as being a frustrating decision for the Wii U when it launched. It was hyped up as a sign of better 3rd party support after the Wii and a Mass Effect game finally coming to a Nintendo system. However, it seemed so stupid to release the 3rd game when neither the first or the second had been released on a Nintendo system at that point. Why buy the Wii U just to play the third title? And even worse, EA further handicapped it by releasing a box set of the full trilogy of Mass Effect for XBox 360 and PS3 at the same price as the single Mass Effect 3 Wii U game. I suppose trying to port 3 games to the Wii U would be more work than just doing the latest game that had come out but for a story heavy series that did things based on decisions you made in past entries it just always seemed so dumb to release the conclusion by itself. The solution to present an animated comic that supposedly takes 20 minutes to show what happened in the first two games just further illustrates how dumb the idea was to release the third game on its own like that. With EA soon pulling the plug on Wii U support, it always seems like they purposefully did this to give them a quick excuse to say they tried but you just can't sell third party stuff on a Nintendo system. And that's the main way I remember Mass Effect 3.

Gonna pause it there.
Whoever said, "Cheaters never win" must've never met Khushrenada.