This post will attempt to predict Gamespot score for Resident Evil 4 using its past scores of other Resident Evil games among other data. I know there are other threads on this, but I don't think they are as scientific as this one. They are more opinioned based. In other words mine is special because I got stats.
Greg Kasavin will do the review for this game, and it will be posted Monday night. For some of his notable reviews he gave a 8.7 to MGS3:SE, a 9.5 to World of Warcraft, and a 9.7 to Metroid Prime.
Gamespot has reviewed 22 Resident Evil Games(Resident Evil(PS)10-25-1996 to Resident Evil Outbreak(PS2)3-31-2004). The average for these 22 reviews are 6.89.
The average of the best versions of the games in the main series is 8.72
Resident Evil 0(GCN)8.0
Resident Evil(PS)8.2
Resident Evil:Remake(GCN)8.9
Resident Evil 2(N64\PS)8.9
Resident Evil 3:Nemesis(PS)8.8
Resident Evil:Code Veronica(DC)9.5
The average score for other recently released high profile AAA games is 9.14
Half Life 2(PC)9.2
Doom 3(PC)8.5
Metroid Prime 2 Echoes(GC)9.1
Halo 2(XBOX)9.4
Grand Theft Auto San Andreas(PS2)9.6
Metal Gear Solid 3:Snake Eater(PS2)8.7
World of Warcraft(PC) 9.5
Facts (Taken from gamerankings.com)
-No game in the last 2 years has gotten higher than a 9.6
-The average score from Gamespot is 67.9.
-Gamespot reviews are higher than average 43.9% of the time and lower than average 56.1% of the time.
-There is a 2.6 point difference between IGN-Cube and Gamespot Reviews. That would give Resident Evil 4 a 95.4(98-2.6) if it holds true.
Top Scores (Taken from gamerankings.com)
-The last game (1 of 4) to get a perfect score was Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3(PS2). 10/28/2001
-The last game to get a 9.9 score was Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2(DC). 11/6/2000
-The last game to get a 9.8 was Wario Land 3(GBC). 6/1/2000
-The last game to get a 9.7 was Metroid Prime(GC). 11/17/2002
-The last game to get a 9.6 was Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas(PS2). 10/26/2004
-The last game to get a 9.5 was World of Warcraft(PC). 11/23/2004
Conclusion:
I think the most important part is the score they gave Code Veronica which was a 9.5. Obviously RE4 is the better game. I think that 9.5 was a slight overrate. My prediction of Gamespot RE4 Score is a 9.5. There are three reasons I won't go any higher.
1. It has a slightly harsh reviewer.
2. Gamespot has been stingy with very high scores over that last two years.
3. Gamespot score is usually lower than Cube-IGN score.
Score 9.5 Gamespot Editors Choice
Gameplay 9
Graphics 10
Sound 9
Value 9
Tilt 10