Listened to the whole thing, it's pretty good and polished!
Some feedback:
+ Good rapport between you two, some good jokes towards the end.
+ Y'all both have good radio voices.
+ Sounds like a comfortable conversation, no obvious silences or fledgling around for talking points (could be good editing).
+ Production sounds great, no popping mic levels, no obvious volume differences, music fades into conversation meaning no abrupt transitions, not much talking over each other, no dead silence.
+ Like the lil' music parts, did you guys make these yourselves? Nice jazzy Rhodes-esque piano.
- Maybe don't start on an ass-grabbing joke, even if you acknowledge its tackiness. Now the save just sounds casually dismissive. Maybe some people will find it funny, but that didn't land for me and it's not a great start within the first minute.
- It's not... immediately obvious what the podcast is about or will entail? You guys clearly have a structure: new business/news/backlog/fun fact to end the show on. Maybe lay that out in the intro, especially if you're doing news? "Today we're talking Crackdown 3, Final Fantasy 9, and Gamepass on Switch rumours." I have the same complaint with something like RFN by the way; if you're producing over an hour of content, consider telling what to roughly expect in that hour.
- In theory I like the idea of doing news segments, but I think it's only really worth pursuing if the format is meant for weekly instalments. The news cycle is fast and most people have already landed on a source to get their news; your additional value is likely going to be commentary, at best. I knew all the stories here already and that's from someone in an isolated Nintendo bubble.
- I'd consider bringing the length down to an hour maybe, depending on how you envision the show yourselves. Do you want to cover a lot of topics, several news stories, etc.? Then maybe quicken the pace/trim some fat in the discussions if possible. If it's more a meandering, conversational flow you're aiming for (seems to work well here), maybe cut one topic?
- Not loving the logo yet. It's not very easy to read with the fade in the middle, and the fonts feel a bit incogruently styled at the moment. I couldn't do better, mind, but it's not very enticing to click yet.