I really struggle with reconciling two notions of post-high school education: on the one hand, many view the education as utilitarian: get a degree, get a better job. On the other hand, my personal experience is that it wasn't until university that I became a person. Before that, I was just a dumb kid. University opened my world and I am not sure anything else could have done that in the same way. But its a very expensive and time consuming lesson that can be gotten in other ways. You can just choose to open your own world to other experiences, while working, and, y'know, just go to the fucking library occasionally. I get that.
I also am not doing now anything remotely like what I started off studying in university. Even during my post-grad degree, which led more closely into my current work, I studied a branch of topics that I didn't end up pusuing in my work.
So, if i just looked at higher education as utilitarian, I would have to conclude I wasted my time and money. But I don't think that at all. University did more for me as a person than I could ever have anticipated and I'm not sure I can measure. Partly, this is becaise I embraced what university offered. As I said earlier, my regret is not embracing everything I could have.
So, now I have kids, the oldest of whom is just finishing juniour high. Soon he will be facing questions about higher education. He'll probably go, but what kind of education will he pursue? Will he go strictly utlitarian and get trade training or an employement-focussed college degree? Or will he go for the full-on university undergrad with the expectation of spending more time specializing with post-grad work? The former is certainly faster and cheaper and will, all going well, lead sooner into decent employment, wages and the path to career advancement. This could in turn facilitate things like marriage, house, kids; good stuff like that. The long university route might make him a deeper thinker or a more well-rounded person but it might not. Its also long and expensive. Its inherently risky but with potentially bigger rewards. Like I say, I struggle.
Ulitimately, its not my decision. Also, I have to remember not to be so fatalistic. One crossroads decision at age 18 isn't set in stone. You can always take different paths as you go along in life. I've taken many myself. Many haven't worked out but I've certainly gotten something out of each.