Topic: Mafia XXXIX Star Wars Mafia: REBEL ALLIANCE - Conclusion

[Dasmos]

I'm pretty sure you had been playing strangely and people suspected you of being the Godfather.

Also on Day 1 I was ready to exchange role PM's with vudu because I had no idea they were all the same, but he was a jerk about it so I didn't.

[Mop it up]

I don't know why. I was playing like a confused townie that nobody ever PM'd. Do you honestly think I'm some bimbo who is too stupid to send in the hit? Thanks for the vote of confidence.

[Dasmos]

Mafia members play the confused townie all the time. Look at Pale, he has played the confused townie in every single game he has participated in.

[Mop it up]

I guess so. But I still think that Khushrenada should have realized that I wouldn't have missed the hit on the first day if I were the godfather.

[GoldenPhoenix]

I guess so. But I still think that Khushrenada should have realized that I wouldn't have missed the hit on the first day if I were the godfather.

Sexism he thinks because you are a woman that you can't accomplish a hit like a man.

[GoldenPhoenix]

Story and poll to come within the next 2 years.

[that Baby guy]

I guess so. But I still think that Khushrenada should have realized that I wouldn't have missed the hit on the first day if I were the godfather.

You seem like exactly the person that would miss a hit.  You play yourself as someone "innocent" very often, and my impulses were that if anyone were to look for a way to win, but still directly kill as few people as possible, it would be you.

So there :p

[Stratos]

I guess so. But I still think that Khushrenada should have realized that I wouldn't have missed the hit on the first day if I were the godfather.

You seem like exactly the person that would miss a hit.  You play yourself as someone "innocent" very often, and my impulses were that if anyone were to look for a way to win, but still directly kill as few people as possible, it would be you.

So there :p

The Benevolent Godfather. Would be interesting if we could try that for a mafia rule set. Give the GF their hit, but make there be an incentive for not using your hits, like a bonus or a punishment. Maybe killing off a townie would cause a mafia member to die as well.

[BeautifulShy]

I don't think that would work to well Stratos. The host would have to have to set up things to happen on certain days. It would be a guessing game on the GF's part. To much risk without equal reward in my opinion.

[Stratos]

It could work. Make it like a 33% chance that a mafia hit will cost the GF a mafia person. Wasn't there one game we played where the GF chose a member to carry out the hit and that member could be caught or killed. Say he hit the bomb, the bomb and the mafia member would die.

[BeautifulShy]

But what type of reward would you have for the GF not making the hit?

[Stratos]

I was saying either a reward or a punishment. One or the other. A one time reward could be an investigation on a player or a vote change in the days poll.

[Mop it up]

I guess so. But I still think that Khushrenada should have realized that I wouldn't have missed the hit on the first day if I were the godfather.

You seem like exactly the person that would miss a hit.  You play yourself as someone "innocent" very often, and my impulses were that if anyone were to look for a way to win, but still directly kill as few people as possible, it would be you.

So there :p

Once again, you are absolutely wrong about me. I don't "play" innocent, I am innocent. You just don't want to admit when you make a mistake.

[that Baby guy]

I did make a mistake!  I'm telling you my thought process behind it, so everyone understands how the mistake was made.

The hope is that it makes me less threatening when I say everything out loud.

[Mop it up]

So you're not going to accuse me of being Mafia the next time I'm investigated as a townie and am genuinely confused?

[that Baby guy]

I can accuse you of being mafia whenever I want.  You can be confused whenever you feel it's right for you.  I don't see how the matters are anything more than coincidence.

Seems like a mafia tactic to me, if I've ever seen one.

[Mop it up]

See, you don't learn from your mistakes.

Being confused is apparently dangerous. It isn't something I "feel is right", it just happens. If you think I have some extreme grip on this game then you're overestimating my ability. Which is why I'd rather stay away from you because I know you think it is better to kill me than trust me regardless of my role.

[that Baby guy]

Aren't you the one that said you didn't plan to ever trust me in mafia?  That's simply the reason why I don't initially try to even work with you at this point.  When we did receive absolute verification, I did try to add you in and vouch that you were certainly not mafia, and you chose to insult the group.

In fact, how many times have I killed you?  Never?  Oh, yeah, that's right.  Never.  We can work on that, if you want.

[Mop it up]

I'm not going to trust you if you never give me a reason. I don't see how that's an "insult". If there is a benefit from trusting you, and it outweighs the risk, then I would. But you've never offered me anything I could have used, so there hasn't ever been a good reason, unless you're going to vote for me when I'm a confirmed townie. Then I wouldn't have a choice, I guess.

You haven't killed me because I've been smart enough to never give you a chance. And because Stratos takes priority over you. Since I go after him, you never really have a reason to come after me.

[Dasmos]

Why are you always so stevey-like and trying to vote off one person? No one likes the person who does that all the time, no one. That's why stevey gets voted out all the time.

[Mop it up]

Because I think it is funny. I never seriously try to vote him out, I just do that until something better comes along. Usually that happens after the first day, but this time it took two days.

[Dasmos]

No one is laughing.

[Mop it up]

I'm laughing. And the point of this game is to amuse myself, so that's all that matters to me.

[Dasmos]

Ahaha I'm kidding. I guess it's pretty funny when you try and vote out one person, albeit not seriously. I'll try it it with vudu next game.

[Stratos]

I think it is funny that she has this strange vendetta against me. Makes the first day even more interesting.