I just finished this game the other day (thanx Steam, more than worth my $5). Zelda rip-off? sure. GoW inspired? of course. Weapon idea from Krull? Most definitely.
But it was fun and interesting. The back tracking was a little annoying, but it is mostly all optional.
And for as fun as the first one was, I can only imagine how they are gonna do the sequel now that his 3 partners in crime are on their way
Hookshot, "boomerang", sword with spin attack, horseback fighting, larger than life bosses, shadow fight, hidden chest, fetch quest, weapon and armor upgrades, lots of blood and souls, grave yard, swimming, puzzles, adventure, flying gliding, climbing, swinging, portals, sand worms, guns, bombs, decapitation, dismemberment, exploding carcasses, snatching hearts from the chest of live creatures, parallel dimension, annoying companion and a bad ass main character. I think this game pretty much has it all in there (except for sex, nudity & Fishing.... can you believe that there was no fishing in this game!?).
I await Darksiders II on WiiU. If it's as least as good as this one was, it will be worth the play through (and I don't finish many games anymore).