So every action is a night action, right?
Beyond that, a little bit of perusal of the rules revealed that this is one of those tricky games (Almost like mine, last time!), where the investigator can't necessarily rely on his investigations.
Since that's the case, I'd say roles probably shouldn't publically reveal themselves: A mafia member could claim to have said role, and in the end, the only way to learn who was who is to vote out on of the players, and we'd have a 50/50 chance of getting that right.
That said, if one player with a role were to do a public reveal, the best option would be the "Orange Paddle." Upon this, the doctor could protect him each night, and players would be insane to lead a vote against him. Still, the matter remains that very easily, a mafia member could also claim he or she has the ability, and in the end, the real "Orange Paddle" would only be known to the mafia, while players would risk their own lives determining who to vote away. Still, had there been no "Clear Paddle," this would be an awesome unifying role. So, I'd say as soon as "Elusive Lucy" is lynched, this player could come forward. Any time before that, though, could just get a couple extra townies in trouble...
...Unless the Orange Paddle and a townie to lead a vote against the possible mafia member feel brave enough to throw their lives away to find a mafia member, that is. Anyone sign up that didn't want to play?
In the mean time, I'm gonna un-vote stevey for standard reasons, as a placeholder vote: He doesn't work well with others, and plays only for his own victory, which isn't cool by my standards. This'll probably change later in the day, as I find someone better to go after.
Edit: As per UncleBob's request, I tossed in Drew_MG's list of players into his post. Drew_MG, if you'd prefer I didn't do that, then just let me know, and I'll stay out of the game in any regard like that. Otherwise, I can help make sure topics are locked at the right time, and such.
Edit: undid vote for stevey.