If there's an even vote and everyone votes, all the players that have been voted for to make the tie die, and they all get to choose one more player to take with them. Ties aren't safe, at all, though, for reasons Spak mentioned. If not everyone has voted, then a random player who has not voted will die.
As far as the whole picture goes, Spak, it looks to me like you must've sent it, then hit Kashogi, because your plan was to target me and NickMitch. I can't find any other reason why you would've hit Kashogi. DAaaMan died from that picture, innocently died. There's no way he would have just made it up and posted it, because if he were wrong, he would've just risked his life for nothing, and if right, he would've likely been a mafia target. Instead, we voted him out with the understanding that we had to have killed one mafia member by the end of today, and we had narrowed it down to two. It was you or DAaaMan, and we voted DAaaMan first, just because Kashogi wildly claimed innocence and last time you did this, you acted differently.
It's clear you acted differently because this all was a fake, but you must've known you could only possibly hide that you faked for one day, which must be why you included me and NickMitch in the thing, so you could slither around dying yesterday, kill Kashogi last night, and then blame me and NickMitch today. Was that the plan all along? I'll admit, it was clever, but it's not going to work Everyone keeps asking me why I'm still alive at this point, plain and simple, it looks like I've been kept alive to be used in this set-up.