I agree they aren't as good as the old games, I also don't think the new Mario games are as good as the old games. But I think it is for different reasons than what is stated. I honestly think it is perception and nothing more. Sonic is percieved to be Mario's enemy so Mario fans byd efault hate him and will find a way or reason to bash him. Prove me wrong but nobody has been able to do that. I grew up in a Sega dominant part of the world, so my perceptions are screwed. I don't care if it is the norm or not, all I care about is if I can find the good in the games, why can't everybody else? See the thing of it is despite the l;ack luster reviews and internet bashing the games still sell so therefore enough people find them playable they will continue to sell. Because it is perception. Case in Point.
My nephew who was only 7 years old LOVES all the new Sonic games, but does not care for the old ones as much. He also loves Mario Sunshine quit a bit. There is nothing unplayable or inherently bad about any of the new "Sonic" games, notice I do not lump Shadow in with that and it's not right to, Luigi's Mansion does not get lumped in with the other Mario games so stop bringing it up in a Sonic discussion. It falls under Spin-Off category. Same with the Extreme sports games like Riders, those are the equivalent of Mario Sports. Not the main serious, not relevant to the point.
Back to why I think Sega would be a good publisher, screw the fanboys on either side,
Sega bleeds a lot of money, just like Sony and MS, but one thing they are good at is marketing their games. The give them a pretty decent push whereas most other publishers who develop for the Wii don't. Plus unlike most other publishers, Sega has never said anything bad, publicly about the Wii or Nintendo in recent years. Hell they sing more praises of the Wii than anyone outside of Nintendo and their Wii offerings are better than most who cres if they are DC ports, isn't that better than Babyz Dance Off and Petz is for Kidz garbage that is flooding the Wii?
God you bring up Sega's best games and trash them for not being original? Nintendo's BEST games aside from Wii Fit and Wii Play on the Wii are ALL DIRECT SEQUELS, which you also COMPLAIN ABOUT. So don't talk **** on Sega for trying a little harder than even Nintendo is.