Topic: I need some feedback please

[bosshogx]

Hey all,

I'm looking for some feedback on a new website some friends and I are going to be setting up this summer.  The promo site will be going up soon as a place holder, with the actual site to follow.

My question is on the front page, we will have a daily topic with replies section.  It is set up so that a news topic can be discussed by the people running the website, not unlike the way Penny Arcade does.  If we have a topic that gets two or three responces, it will start running down the main page.  So, the question is, would you rather scroll down a page to read topics or would you rather have the topic contained in it's own window with it's own scroll bar instead?

Any feedback would be greatly appretiated.

Thanks!  

[18 Days]

Scroll down the page. It's convention for a reason.

[Nick DiMola]

Quote
Originally posted by: 18 Days
Scroll down the page. It's convention for a reason.

[bosshogx]

Mr. Jack: I assume your agree with 18 days?

Most people have been telling me they would rather have scrolling over iframe.  Anyone actually disagree?

[segagamer12]

I say design the site how you want it and then if you get negative feedback adjust to that but make it look like a site you would visit first.


BTW you never answered my PM.

[bosshogx]

It seems most site, and people for that matter, prefer to scroll.  Looks like we'll start that way and change it accordingly.  Oh, sorry about the PM sega, I took care of it.

[MarioAllStar]

Frames are dead. Make 'em scroll.

[thetransformerscollector]

hey bosshogz this is segagamer12 I got logged out last night and the systems changed my password on me  so I am having trouble logging back in could you resend whatever your pm was to *this* account until they get it fixed. I dont know how long it takes to retrieve a lost password so it could be best to just use this account for a day or two. thanx.