I definately see the sameness of Xbox and Playstation titles a problem.
In my collection I only own like 2 FPS. 2 Fighters. A couple of RPGs. A Couple of Platformers. A Couple of Puzzle games. And finally a few Sports Games.
When I look at the mainstream games for Xbox 360 and Playstation 3 I see more of the same period.
Realistic War Simulators (First Person and Third) How many of those do you really need?
Free Roaming Crime playground games. (Grand Theft Auto Types) This is one of the most overrated genres ever. Yes, I can do anything I want from the beginning of the game. But why does it all relate to do the samething over and over again?
Shooters: Be it First Person, or Third Person. They all have the same atmosphere, similar stories and directions, and they just don't interest me anymore. All I need is one single great multiplayer First Person experience and I am happy....not 100.
Sports Games: Again, I just need one of each sport I am interested in...and that isn't very many.
There is nothing new.
At least with Nintendo. Their franchises are pretty varied. Mario is nothing like Zelda. Zelda is nothing like Metroid. Metroid is nothing like Star Fox.
There is alot of variety in not just games, but in presenation and personality with the system. The same can't be said about other systems. (Jaks and Daks is a great example. Its a platformer/shooter, but its just as dark and moody as everything else out there.)
For my personal tastes, Microsoft and Sony has nothing for me. Period.