Quote
Originally posted by: Arbok
Quote
Originally posted by: Kairon
We ARE still talking about an RPG...right?
What was your reaction to Super Mario RPG's story then? Or the one in Pokémon?
Super Mario RPG was eh to me, I mean, it had a clever role reversal for Bowser, but Geno, in my opinion, threatened to overshadow Mario as a Hero (which to me was uncool), and the game didn't pretend to be more than it was (Unlike TOS, which in my oinion gives lip service to addressing racism and the-world-is-worth-saving stuff). Nevertheless, my brother was the Super Mario RPG fan, not me. I'm the Paper Mario Fan.
Pokemon as an RPG has slightly different elements. If it was a straightforward party-battle system then I'd agree that it sucked. But with the collectathon aspect to it, it actually incentivized a full exploration of its world which shifted the game's immersion focus away from a single narrative thread and instead to location based substories. And again, this game didn't flaunt itself as something more than it was, it didn't have characters going emo to each other and just miraculously working through their issues.
I have more respect for crappy/mediocre RPGs that don't pretend to be more than they are (Quest 64) than RPGs that insult my intelligence by preaching about peace and energy and all that wonderful, wonderful stuff. I eman, come on, I'm based in San Francisco, I listen to NPR, I used to live and breath socio-political issues! I want RPGs to challenge me, not make me regress to my intellectual infancy!
...I'm crazy aren't I?
~Carmine M. Red
Kairon@aol.com