Finally rented the game and played through both stories in story mode:
- Is it just me, or does the gameplay feel like classic MK? I know the gameplay has barely evolved from the arcade games, but the removal of multiple fighting stances and gimmicks make it feel like a down to Earth version of MK, making it almost feel like the first MK game. Again, this might just be me...
- The story mode in MK vs. DC might be the best out of all the story modes in past games. First, you actually get to play as the characters rather than a generic character going through a series of mundane events and missions. The story is a little silly, but explains how the universes merged and why everyone felt like beating the crap out of each other. I heard that it was penned by one of DC's writers, so that explains why everything fits so well and feels like a crossover comic.
- I'm somewhat disappointed with the extras. As convoluted and gimmicky the extras were in the past games I really enjoyed unlocking animatic videos, sketches, extra characters and costumes. I thought a game like MK vs. DC would merit a lot of content, especially with the franchise it is dealing with. On the XBL Marketplace you can download videos of the making of the special edition comic and the game cover. Why couldn't we have gotten those videos as extras in the game. But on the other hand it gives the game a more "down to Earth" feel to it, with little gimmicks (save for the crossover of course) out of the way.
- The Joker is AWESOME in this game. To me, he is a mix of Cesar Romero's Joker and Mark Hammill's Joker (I think he does the voice for this game as well...). His scenes with the MK characters are the best in the entire game, if only because the MK characters can't comprehend his persona.
- My 360 is set to Spanish. What really funny is that the announcer actually pronounces the names of the DC characters in perfect Spanish (for example, in Spanish the Green Lantern is called "Linterna Verde". When he wins, the announcer actually says his name in Spanish). I thought it was both a surreal and clever attention to detail, acknowledging the character's presence in foreign markets.
- The main menu is awesome. I love how the battle between Scorpion and Batman plays out while you switch between menus.
- I must say, the games does look better running on my TV than on low res online footage. I still think the characters are a little too stiff and don't animate as well as they should, but still look good.
- Finally, I must give props to Midway for using the DC Heroes license very well. They got the most out of the license and the dedication to the characters, the locales and the story shows. This is unlike Namco who haphazardly added Star Wars characters without a proper storyline or logic (then again, I am sure that while MK vs. DC was planned from the start to be a cross over fighting game Namco added the Star Wars characters at the last minute).
Overall, it was a really solid game with presents both universes in a great light, fighting feels classic and the story is worth going through once. I say rent, though, because its pretty barebones regarding extra features and modes and unless you have friends or a Gold account you might grow bored playing it single player.