Quote
I think Nintendo does need to provide online tools to third parties whether or not they think it's profitable for them to take their own games online. The big players like EA and Ubisoft see online as the "next 3D", and whether or not you agree, if Nintendo doesn't provide some basic support, eventually these companies are going to see dropping sales and will reconsider bringing out versions for Nintendo systems.
I completely agree- even if Nintendo doesn't see the profit in online gaming right now, a lot of other developers do, and it sertainly wouldn't hurt if Nintendo encouraged them to support the Gamecube online.
Quote
I would say that Bill bashed Gamefaqs alot more than I may have and he's on your side of the argument.
I get the distinct impression that Bill was playing along with your comment. It doesn't really matter if he wasn't, though- you were downplaying people who go to GameFAQs because its polls don't support your case.
Quote
p.s. - alot of Cube owners over on the IGN boards are very upset with GC not having any online support, and alot of them are saying they're probably gonna buy an xbox because of it.
THat's exactly what I'm talking about, joe- the opinions of a few internet geeks over at IGN don't mean ANYTHING. It's the overall public, the
huge majority of gamers who don't post on message boards, and right now they're saying they don't care about online gaming!
Quote
Yes online gaming isn't profitable now but I think it's pretty likely it's going to be profitable (or at least at a break-even point) sometime in the future.
No one is saying it won't be profitable in the future, it's just not profitable
now- that much is obvious.
Quote
So when should Nintendo go online? They can't just wait until it is profitable and then say "okay, here's our online plan" when Sony and MS have had working plans for YEARS and have a complete hold of the online gaming market. If you don't take a risk with something new then you'll always be playing catch-up.
Nintendo would only have to play catch up if the online wave hits
this generation, which we know it won't. Next generation user bases start over again at 0, as do online communities. A consumer judges the online potential of a console by looking at its selection of internet enabled games, which means Nintendo simply needs to work off the experience of Sony and MS (ie replicating their good ideas and avoiding their bad ones) and get a comparable amount of 3rd party support for their console. Developers aren't going to look at the online user base of LAST generation because that means nothing THIS generation.
Quote
Plus "it's not profitable" isn't a good reason for most gamers. That's an excuse for investors, not customers.
Let's look at the facts, Ian- just about all gamers have
absolutely no clue what to do when it comes to running a business. Gamers don't need the reason because the vast majority of them don't care enough to want one anyway. Why should Nintendo go out of their way and drop millions of dollars into what is, at this point, a niche gaming market?
Quote
Sony and MS have it so there's no reason in the eyes of a gamer why Nintendo shouldn't have it too.
Except most people don't care about that- you seem to forget this little fact
a lot, Ian.
Nintendo is supposed to be an innovative, progressive, risk-taking, cutting edge developer. They're not supposed to be a conservative developer living in the past.
There's difference between taking a risk and being
stupid. Do you honestly think Nintendo has ignored online gaming completely? When they
say it's not profitable, I'm inclined to believe they've done their homework more than a message board rat, and not just because they have droves of evidence to support them while you don't.
Quote
I didn't become a Nintendo fan because they played it safe. I became a fan because they pushed the envelope and led the industry into the future. I became a fan of the developer that made Super Mario 64 and set the standard for 3D gaming.
I became a Nintendo fan because I loved their games, and I still do. If you don't, I think your problems with Nintendo run much deeper than mere lack of online play or Nintendo's seeming ignorance to the future, or whatever crap you'd like to make up.
Quote
For those who like to think Nintendo going online will magically make like half their problems go away (Seriously, read some of your posts. A few of you sound like this I swear.) you're more or less going to be dead wrong.
Exactly. Very well said, Juan.