He's right about the story. Still, for me anyway, I'm willing to give Mario games a pass on the story department though certain Mario spinoffs like Superstar Saga did pretty well with story.
Anyway, though I haven't finished the game (99 stars so far), some thoughts.
- graphics are awesome. I'm playing on a 40" HDTV with component cables. Gorgeous, despite some crummy textures here and there that are only really noticeable on seldom occasions when the camera wonks out and closes in on an object. Some polygon breakup at times, nothing serious.
- music is absolutely phenomenal and by far my favorite part of the game.
- gameplay is standard Mario affair which is good and bad. Still fun after all these years though it gets boring after a while and I end up putting the game down for several days. Some of the star collecting is just plain not fun. The pranksters comets cheaply extend completion time.
- why did Luigi punk out after like 4 stars? Lazy bastard....