This whole game was a clusterfuck. This is why I hate complicated rules. They leave too many holes, too many one-off situations, and too many interpretations.
The game was fucked on day 2 when thatguy changed the rules so Maxi could come back from the dead.
Had I not done that, you, Khush, and Mop_it_up would have won right there. What I did, instead, made the game easier for the rest of the good guys to win, and only slightly more difficult for you:
Had I left him dead, stevey wouldn't have had to target him on the third night, and kill him himself. Instead, he would have gone after one of you. If you look back, despite what you think, reviving Maxi was to the overall advantage of the good side.
As far as the voting aspect goes, the issue was in my wording. I was asked about it the day before, and I clarified it for someone on the bad side. This is what I said:
It depends:
If a voter's vote was blocked, and that vote were the first vote for vudu, and the next vote in time was against someone else involved in the tie, in that case, the second person would be the one going home, because the first vote didn't actually exist.
If someone receives vote protection, which is different than a voter's vote being blocked, and it were still tied, then whomever had the first vote in the tie would go home.
So yeah, it depends on if the first vote is actually a vote or not, if that makes sense :p
And since Dasmos's vote was in front of Decoyman's vote, you can see the result, yourself.