Topic: Pokemafia: GAME OVER!

[Zach]

Hey, what the heck are you talking about 18 days.  I did what I did because I was trying to win, I wouldn't call our shaky doctors alliance exploitation.

I will admit, you got me pretty good in mafiaV (my first game by the way) But if you remember correctly, In mafia VI I was Nook, and not only did I have everyone thinking I was just a gullible townie, but I also managed to kill you on the very first night.  Looks like you will probably die on the first night in the next game as well because everyone hates you

[18 Days]

Maybe exploited was the wrong word.

And I wont die first!

[Zach]

Well Im not sure what your talking about.   I guess you could be talking about the fact that Dash recruited me that last night (lol, snorlax must have been one heck of a bomb).

[Garnee]

Not cool, not the slightest bit cool.

[wandering]

Quote
Originally posted by: vudu
Wandering and I have a love-hate relationship--he loves me and I hate him.  

Yeah, well, I love me, so it all balances out.

Quote
Originally posted by: NuclearSpeed
hmmm, I thought I had told wandering that I could save him if the rest of XD had wanted him dad. considering I was the assassin I had a lot of say in who to kill.

aha, I know what happened here. You said, if your mafia decided to come after me, it would be botched. What I thought you meant was, our plan to work together would be botched if your mafia decided to kill me...but what you actually meant was, if your mafia tried to kill me, you'd botch it with your special power. Sorry. I've edited my retrospective.

Quote
Originally posted by: TheYoungerPlumber
I abandonned my mafia because I was stuck with only stevey quite quickly.  Not that great a partner....

And yet he DID figure out everyone's roles (including mine, unfortunatley for both me and him)...

Quote
Originally PMed by: stevey
The Snaps Crakely and Pop mafia

Crimm/ Spoink /The Assassin
Stevey/Electrode /Investigator/Godfather
TheYoungerPlumber/Jigglypuff /Doctor Back stabber
couchmonkey/ Psyduck /Security Guard
TVMan/ Slaking /Recruiter

The other guards:

Blackfootsteps / Dragonite - XD
Shyguy / Meowth - Dash
Sir_Stabbalot / Blastoise - townie

The other Investigator

Bill Aurion / Nidoqueen - XD
Nemyhlovecraft / Bulbasaur - dash
Pryopizm / Omanyte - townie

The other assassins

NuclearSpeed / Girafarig - XD
Athrun Zala / Lugia - dash
Wandering / Altaria - townie

the other recruiters
Vudu / Mew - XD
MattVDB / Wobuffet - dash
UncleBob / Calumon - townie

The other Back stabbing doctor

Khushrenada / Pikachu - XD
18 Days / Hoppip - dash
Zach / Snorlax - townie

The townies

Ceric / Farfetch'd
S-U-P-E-R / Voltorb
BlackNMild2k1 / Gastly
Decoyman / Goldeen
Garnee - Zapdos

unknown super serect role

Dasmos - Blaziken

I dont really know what is dasmos's role but for now I guess on bomber or the far more likely town idoit role....

Quote
Originally posted by: NuclearSpeed
]although they then turned around and took out the townie assassin who I thought I had working for us, and was supposed to be going for zach that night he died.

Well, I wasn't going to kill you. And I really WAS planning on going after zach when I said that, as I was fairly sure he was mafia.

...Actually, I don't remember lying a single time the whole game. I think that's a mafia first for me.

[blackfootsteps]

Yeah  Wandering I knew I should have responded straight away to that PM but my teammates decided I shouldn't. We knew Nemy was Dash but we couldn't hit him so we thought we'd get you to do it for us, we so should have followed that through. It was a risky move (to not reply) and luckily you died that night.

Ceric you knew I was Mafia didn't you? Either way, thanks for the help and trust.  

EDIT: Oh yeah Pale one complaint, I didn't really 'die' storyline-wise, you could have made me hit a jumbo jet as I flew away or something. I was really looking forward to having a dead-avatar!

[Ceric]

Yeah.  But towards the end I figured it didn't matter.  Their wasn't enough townies left to make a difference even if voting worked.  

I also thought everyone started with roughly the same info except mafias knew their members.  Yeah.  No wonder most of the game I was wondering how everyone knew so much.

I thought I did well as one of the least informed.

[Zach]

Quote
Originally posted by: Ceric
Yeah.  But towards the end I figured it didn't matter.  Their wasn't enough townies left to make a difference even if voting worked.  

Thats a big part of the reason why I joined the doctors alliance.  The townies seemed like a sinking ship, and I was hoping to survive through the whole game for the first time (which I did, even though I had to commit suicide).

There would have been a decent chance if Matt had made a kill rather than recruited me.  I was thinking that Matt would attack Dasmos, and If I could have saved dasmos, it could have been 2 townies vs one XD (varying depending  on who had to sacrifice themself to kill 18 days)

But then again, its easy to say that if I had better luck earlier in the game, the townies probably would have stood a better chance.  It was kinda funny that everyone was complaining the random number generator succeeded too much (because of 18 days).  I was one of the very few people who complained it didnt succeed enough (because I kept failing).  

[MattVDB]

Oh my gosh, this game was so much fun.  Thank you Pale.  I was surprised to see that I got an actual role, and even more shocked when I became godfather.

The last day was the best part for me though.  I left for the coast Thursday afternoon, so I wasn't around to vote snipe.  Instead I called some people on my cell phone and got them to read me the results.  When I had left it was 1 vote per person.  When I called, it was 2 for me, 2 for Nuclear, and 2 throw aways.  Well, knowing what it would do, I voted for Nuclear as well.  FULLY expecting to be picked as the other death, I was fine with it.  Well, so votes got changed around and it ended up changing to 18 Days and Nuclear, and I freaked out.  I had already put in a request for Zach, but was hesitant to put any faith into that actually happening.  

Well, on the way to the coast, I filled in my friends on how the game was played, and what position I was in at the time.  It looks like we may have some more recruits for next round.  Anyway, Friday morning, when I called to get an update on the game (no internet connection at the beach cabin) I was shocked to hear it had ended.  Even more shocked to hear that I had won.  So, thank you guys for making the game fun.  I had a blast, and it really got some people wanting to play next round.  (Around 7 or so)  So, that's good news, right?

[couchmonkey]

Good ol' Snap:



I thought the game was pretty well designed, though I'd agree that the townies were maybe a little weak compared to the mafias.  Though they did manage to survive to the end in spite of getting blown up by 18 Days over and over again, so maybe I'm being too kind.

Also, being a security guard was kind of poopy.  When I read that if one of us survived, Security Guards could win, I just kinda blinked and said, "But there's no way we'll survive!"  It was still a clever role in the grand scheme of the game, though.

As for how I played, the answer is stupid.  I panicked when everyone started voting Crimm on the second day and drew too much attention to Snap by starting a Khushrenada bandwagon.  In retrospect I should have just left things alone for Crimm to sort out, probably all he had to do was make an appearance to save himself.  Chalk it up to newbie enthusiasm.  Though it was kind of cool how that act changed the way the game played.  

[Pale]

The picture is great.  Especially the facial hair on stevey.    Who's the other chick?

[couchmonkey]

Nurse Joy!  When I gave her a cigarette, I thought the ironing was delicious.