Quote
Originally posted by: Ian Sane
I've never understood it when people praise the PS2 d-pad. I HATE that d-pad. The stupid split design is blister-city. Plus the d-pad centric design is ridiculous for a 3D gaming system. If the Gamecube had a bigger d-pad it wouldn't get dumped on so much and the PS2 controller wouldn't be so praised.
I also feel the PS2 gets a lot of praise because most multiplatform games are designed with that controller in mind thus giving the illusion that it's a better controller. The console leader's controller is always going to get praise because most game are designed for it.
While I agree with you that the analog position is idiocy on the PS2 controller, I still think it's a great design overall. I feel bad for anyone who can get blisters on that d-pad, it's so smooth, low-set, and rounded, it's like Sony went out of it's way to make it comfortable. Having logged over 70 hours each on Street Fighter EX+A (Playstation) and Soul Calibur (Dreamcast), I must admit to absolutely loving the Dreamcast controller as a whole (it is, afterall, the godfather of the whole GBA connectivity thing, but regardless...), but the PS2 d-pad blows it (and it's close cousin, the GC d-pad) out of the water. That said, I think the GC analog stick is a beautiful thing in Soul Calibur 2, working as fluidly as an arcade joystick, but with enough snap (not to mention those great 8-way directional indentations) to pull off typical directional-tab moves with ease.
On a side note, your point that multiplatform games are designed with only the PS2 controller in mind is really only true of crap game studios (see THQ). Some games, like the Harry Potter series, Timesplitters, and Soul Calibur 2 make excellent use of the GC controller. It's usually not even that companies design with the PS2 controller in mind, so much as they design with a traditional arcade setup in mind, at least for the majority of fighters out there.
Off topic somewhat: this has made me realize that every game should include some alternate button configs, if not a total remapping system... Not to mention a screen positioning option.