Quote
Originally posted by: Grey Ninja
Think of it this way.
Would Stephen King be a good children's book writer?
You actually don't know Stephen King that well. (I don't mean on a personal level, but you'd be surprised what he has done, and what he can do, I hear his "On Writing" recommended CONSTANTLY.)
Quote
Would Dr. Seuss make a good horror writer?
Some of his books are scary enough as it is... "Tiny little people live on that flower... SO DON'T STEP ON IT OR THEY'LL RISE UP AND KILL YOU." (Okay, so that's an alternate ending to
Horton Hears a Who, close enough. ;P)
Quote
Would Disney make a good action movie?
Actually... well, you did put in the qualifier "good", but there are several names Disney has gone under or owns for popular movies, such as action... Touchstone, I think Miramax, et cetera.
And even if you discounted all those, some might rate a few of Disney's animated features as good action movies, although they usually lean more towards "Adventure." Like Aladdin for example.
Quote
Would Britney Spears make a good singer?
Make one? Out of what, spare parts she has lying around?
Quote
My point is that EAD doesn't make violent games. To do so would be to go against what they do best. We love EAD for their game making skill at what they do best, by making games for all ages.
I guess the thought is that maybe EAD would be good at more mature-themed games, and just doesn't know it yet because they seemingly haven't attempted to stretch out and try their hand at it. We don't know they're "limited" (don't get me wrong, I love EAD's games, just speaking from a developmental capability here) to only making "all ages" games. Don't forget even _Miyamoto_ mentioned they were being a little creatively styfuled when Hiroshi Yamauchi was "Executive Producer" of every Nintendo game project, and when even Miyamoto says he was being limited, you know that man (Yamauchi) had an iron fist on what Nintendo put out to the market, and that was that. It's possible they had the idea or inkling before, but not really the OK to do so.
The secondary point could be this: Some gamers always complain mature-themed games are "style with no substance." So, if a dev house famous for quality gameplay could get that right mix together for their own project, it'd really be a highly-regarded game that both casual gamers and the hardcores would take note of.
I don't think anyone's for "forcing" EAD into making a game they don't want to make, but it'd be an interesting project to see if they tried.