Either Garnee or Blackfootsteps was getting voted out, depending on the whim of the local prostitutes. Spoiler: they decided on the bolded name and lucky for them, a Mad Gear goon was voted out. And by voted out, I mean beaten with plumbing.
So Mad Gear chopped up Mario, who was Poison, and mailed the pieces his/her parents. They were so proud. Well, not really.