Topic: Crisis Day 2 Earth Alpha

[Spak-Spang]

Events so far:

Pyropizm was voted out...but saved by the Doctor.
Vudu was hit by the Mafia.  Vudu was the Brother.
Stevey was killed by a crazy Killer.  Stevey was the Detective


Day 2 Starts now...I will try to write a story soon...but hey those are the events.

[Khushrenada]

Does the doctor know something I don't? Or is the doctor a new player and assumed I was telling the truth about being mafia and therefore protected Pyropizm?

Well, if at first you don't succeed, ..... kill the doctor.

un-Vote UncleBob

[Spak-Spang]

So Alpha managed a little better than its Sister dimension.  But does that mean good fortune in the future?

2 important townie roles were lost in Alpha...but that does not mean defeat...

[Pryopizm]

Vote Khush for being evil in two places at once.  And big thanks to whoever the doctor was.  I'm just a townie (yeah, yeah, i know, we all are), but still appreciate still being in the game.  I'd offer to let me get killed again next time these fools vote me out and save someone else, but that will depend on how many good guys are still left. 

We still got the bounty hunter; so hopefully he'll make a good hit soon.  Like Khush, if no one else ends up voting for him.

[Shift Key]

VOTE KHUSH

I don't like how you survived in both dimensions. I'm seeing red flags everywhere at the moment, but this one is the most obvious one.

[Dasmos]

vote removed

Yeah nothing better than hearsay here either.

[RABicle]

Someone kill Shifty in Earth BETA, I'm pretty sure I told him in caht that I was the bounty hunter. And you know what my power was? Oh just killing the crazy killer on THIS world! He's probably the crazy killer as well as the mafia godfather of BETA!

vote Shift-Key

[Khushrenada]

Vote Shift Key

I'm seeing red flags too.

[Khushrenada]

So, did some thinking about this game and came to a few easy conclusions. the two roles left in this earth are  the killer and doctor. This is proved by the fact that they both had an action in this world. That leaves the witness and tough guy in Beta Earth.

Here are some things to ponder:

Why did the killer choose stevey to die? He hadn't even posted. Was it a grudge?

DaaMan64 said he had a role in this world but it was not mafia. If that is the case, he is the doctor or the killer.

We know Pyro isn't the doctor by process of elimination. His townie claim could be taken at face value. If so, what does that leave us?

Let's say that Shift Key's claim about being innocent on one world means you are guilty on another is correct. If that is the case, we should target the Rat. He was a townie on Beta, therefore, he must have an ability on Alpha. Of the abilities left on alpha, 4 are mafia, one is a killer and the last is the doctor. The odds are in our favor that he is guilty.

[UncleBob]

You analysis assumes that all of the roles are known.

[Spak-Spang]

Now that I have corrected the list of roles...all roles should be announced.

 

[Khushrenada]

And why is that so hard to believe? People tell me their roles all the time and I'm quite good at deduction. Plus, I seem to have the luck of the devil so to speak when it comes to making good guesses.

Unless you have some hidden role you'd like to share about, Godfather Bob.

[DAaaMan64]

Look I don't know who to trust, and I'm sorry it's only the second day, I'm pretty much going to with the bandwagon.  It seems we have a tie right now, I'm willing to break a tie, but I don't like it. 

Look at the list of people that are usually talking, for example, EasyCure hasn't hesitated to update the song thread, but he hasn't said **** of anything in here.

[animecyberrat]

vote kush

he talks too much.

[Plugabugz]

vote nickmitch

[animecyberrat]

does the doctor fly around between the two worlds in a little blue box? If not your mafia is dead to me.

[EasyCure]

Look I don't know who to trust, and I'm sorry it's only the second day, I'm pretty much going to with the bandwagon.  It seems we have a tie right now, I'm willing to break a tie, but I don't like it. 

Look at the list of people that are usually talking, for example, EasyCure hasn't hesitated to update the song thread, but he hasn't said **** of anything in here.

lol thats cuz i'm at work and whenever i'm n the forums at work i start reading the older post before the newer ones and work my way up the list. Besides i like the Song Titles thread more than mafia right now since this is my first "real" mafia game and i dont know what i'm doing, other than going with the bandwagon.

vote Khushrenada cuz he talks too much and i've heard he's not to be trusted

[DAaaMan64]

vote nickmitch

hmmm... not a word in those whole thread. You right.  He WILL DIE

vote Nickmitch

[Khushrenada]

vote kush

he talks too much.

And he's right.

Except for one matter. It appears some roles have the ability to work interdimensionally. Meaning that the killer and doctor may not be confined to one univers after all. Which makes sense. Why would only one universe be affected by the killer and doctor while another universe has two night watchers.

My mistake. Now that I've corrected myself, it's time you did the same and change your vote away from me. I'm not your enemy.

[stevey]

Khush Vote

Dirty killer

[nickmitch]

Vote Shift Key

I'm seeing red flags too.

You're only seeing an oppurtunity to save your own ass. Admit it Khush!

vote nickmitch

hmmm... not a word in those whole thread. You right.  He WILL DIE

vote Nickmitch

I've been at work all day, and I can't goof off as much as I'd like to. My apologies.

[NWR_insanolord]

I believe Khush, but since he's doomed I won't bother voting for someone else.

[Dasmos]

Khush Vote

Dirty killer

lol stevey. you're dead in alpha.

i'm still not convinced that basing a vote on past instances is the best method to shoot for everytime. i hope this doesn't become the trend for the rest of the game.

watch this turn out to be true though, and then there's me sitting there like an idiot.

[Spak-Spang]

The Tally as of now is:

Khush- 4
Shift Key- 2
nickmitch- 2

We have 1 1/2 hours left.

[Khushrenada]

I believe Khush, but since he's doomed I won't bother voting for someone else.

Well, thanks a lot dude. I hope this isn't mafia posturing saying you believe I'm innocent knowing full well that I am but refusing to join me in a vote since it targets a fellow mafia mate.



In other news, when I'm not being cynical, I'd like to say this. I've only been voted out once in a mafia game and I'd like to keep that special record for the few people who voted me out, Zach, Decoyman, DrewMD and Dasmos.

But, aside from tarnishing that legacy, I'd also like to point out the logical reasons to keep me alive.

Shift Key asserts that I am guilty on Earth. His reason is speculation. He therefore is having everyone kill one innocent Khushrenada. Let's say he's correct. This means that on one Earth, the townies are going to fall even further behind. Another townie dead and a free mafia hit.

Yet, how do we know that Shift Key is innocent on both worlds? For all we know, he could be mafia on one world and is having you kill an innocent me to further his mafia. He has said that he doesn't know which world has an innocent version but I don't believe that is true. I think he does know and is setting up the townies to help his mafia get closer to victory.

Would not that logical choice be to leave me alive at night? If I'm innocent, one mafia is sure to target me tonight, most likely both. But, it means the mafia's will waste their hits on me. Perhaps even the killer will waste his hit on me. But it also means you will be protected at night. There's a greater chance that I am killed than there is that any other player will be targetted. So, for your own safety, why not keep me alive at night?

Second, if Shift Key is right, that means that after tonight, I should be alive in at least one world since I should be mafia. So, why waste a vote on an innocent when you can get the guilty part in a correct vote tomorrow? Wouldn't it be better to make your votes count for something today?

For these reasons, I urge you to vote Shift Key. I make more sense than he does and I've disproved all his theories.