This is interesting, Pale. Lots of thought clearly went into this, and I like the wrinkle having three Mafias brought (there was even the possibility for a townie to pretend to be Mafia if he was gutsy enough... not sure what benefit it would've brought, but it would have allowed some mystery about which mafia he belonged to.... never figured out how to take advantage of that, unfortunately)
But there's one thing I don't understand... Why have Doctors protect their fellow Doctors?
Realistically, why would a doctor from a competing team want to save a member of another team? Regardless, it had an unforeseen consequence, at least for me... one of my first notes was, "Zach = Townie Doctor?" After I (and my townie bud Ceric) began wondering how 18 days kept surviving vote-offs, we came to the conclusion that they must've recruited a Doctor to their side, namely ours, and that was why both Nemy and 18 Days wouldn't die. So, I ruled Zach out from that time as being a townie (even if he had been at some point), and never tried to contact him. In essence, it kept some townies from forming up. And ironic as it is, he would be the last townie left... because he was saved by 18 days, whom he later saved... Overall it would've been better for the townies had Zach just died that day. Apparently, it formed a bond of trust between Zach and Dash, which they would later take advantage of
But yeah, I had a great time anyways. All the espionage, the deductions, the hidden motives, the sad but relieved feeling you get when you see that your co-conspirator has died and is revealed as a townie, but at least you were right in putting your trust in him. Ceric, if you hadn't turned out to be a townie, I would've felt just betrayed, lol.
Congrats, Dash. You did best at what you didn't want - living - but it brought about your ultimate desire in the end. And 18 days had me fooled right up till that first vote
I even sent her a message that very night "I think you're a townie, team up pardner blahblah" Ah, dumb mistake.
But the stupid mistakes made it fun, too. Overall, well done, Pale.
So... when's the next game? ^_^