Hey guys,
Thanks for keeping the conversation going. Sorry for my silence.
I can second @Loverde now. I received a copy that looked exactly like that.
I took it back as soon as I got it because I wound up getting a complete, Like New edition for $85. I missed out on the coupon codes, but it was worth the extra bucks to get the whole thing for me. That said, the GameStop copy was excellent if I were to have not cared about the extra goodies. The disc certainly looked brand spanking new. For that matter, so did the manual and case. Certainly an interesting situation...
Thanks for posting pictures, @Loverde. If anyone wants to know what mine looked like, see those pictures. Carbon copy.