Is anyone really surprised at number 2? Well, if you haven't been around the site as long as some of us, it might be.
Like I said on the page, this game is extremely addicting and was indeed a hot import. I remember NWR gave a copy of the game away during one of the anniversary events, and eventually I got to play it myself. I fell in love with it the minute I started playing. And I even defended Elite Beat Agents when it first came out, since, you know, Japan > The Rest of the World in the eyes of some :p .
I even made a thread detailing the changes made to each of the songs in EBA, and of course wrote about the sad stories for the emotional Nintendo moments.