It's the BEST show on TV! I'm as big a Lost and AD fan as anyone, but Battlestar is just ummmm AMAZING.
Forget everything you know about sci-fi shows. Forget it. This is the most dramatic, harshest and realistic sci-fi show ever.
"BUT I'S HATEZ SCI-FIZES DURHHRHR!" Ok, so maybe you do. Ask yourself this: would you be willing to watch a military show? Or at least give one a try? If so, Battlestar is for you. If you like sci-fi, Battlestar is for you. If you like drama, Battlestar is for you. If you like amazing TV, Battlestar is for you.
It's film documentary style with dark toned interiors and oversaturated exteriors. It has one of the most unique scores ever, as far removed from Star Wars (and the original series) as you can get. It has great effects (for TV) that it only uses when needed. There are NO CHEESY ALIENS or freaky languages. It's about real people fighting a war. It's got some of the mystery and myth of Lost, plus some of the absolute best acting on TV. The writing is sharp, intelligent and biting. Its full of political commentary but doesn't try and be topical. It's for adults and it's the best sci-fi show EVER.
So...try it!