It took me way too long to notice what Zap's avatar was.
Sonic is kind of like the Simpsons in that it has been going on for so long past the best before date that you realize the good stuff is the minority. The good stuff is so old and outnumbered by the bad that if you only like the good stuff you're so out of the loop with the series as a whole that you probably couldn't even call yourself a fan and certainly couldn't relate with someone who truly is a fan of the whole thing.
Sonic has also passed this point where if the series got back on track would we notice? I've heard enough Sonic fans go on about how THIS game is the return to form with practically every new release so if it truly got good again I wouldn't believe their testimony and go try it out. How do you take the testimony of someone that has put up with so many mediocre or outright crummy releases at face value? Do they even know what a good Sonic game would be like, because good compared to Sonic 2006 isn't necessarily anything to write home about?