So, just to weigh-in a little:
Khuhsrenada's consistently being in the crosshairs early-on definitely helped as it resulted in the alternative vote being a somewhat random choice instead. Unfortunate stalemate, but in a way Khushrenada getting out of the game probably helped clear the logjam for townies so there wasn't such a specific target to start each day. This is the first true error i'd attribute myself for agreeing to and joining in on that vote. If we could have milked him as cover for a day or so more, it maybe would have helped clinch the win. Khush also was the only one besides maybe Mop-it-up that had overt suspicion of me as a mafia, so who knows.
Second true error was on the day Luigi Dude was voted out, Insanolord & I could have gotten the vote switched to someone else and saved him. Likely would have Outed us as mafia, but maybe the sparing one extra day of not being voted out would have been enough? Tough to tell.
Us Wesker mafia had blunders of targeting Pokepal and then Mop-it-up on nights where it was most likely they'd be protected, losing two separate chances to whittle down numbers quickly was a huge loss. Then being borg'd into the Ashford mafia threw everything out the window of how to approach things.
Pokepal's hail mary plan was probably the best angle we had, but it was hamstrung by 1) me being busier than expected at work during the last day game, and 2) me having been relatively quiet through several days, making me tossing accusations and claims of knowledge around in the day thread more suspicious. Sorry to Pokepal that I wasn't available to do the full court press, but I was probably also NOT the right partner for that strategy either, unfortunately.
Regardless, good game everyone. Wish it would have resulted in a Mafia win instead, but ces la vie. I like the game format though, the second mafia group really changes things up.