Oh, I'm sure you guys would buy it all over again on your GBAs...
Unfortunately, I'm not being sarcastic. Come on, I know that time can make anything seem nostalgic, but Yoshi's Story was a weak, weak game. I heard practically nothing but complaints when it came out, and I'm not talking about people expecting a "cool" game, but many found it annoying, others way too easy, and the few that DID like it found it way, way too short. (Even after NoA added in that extra "Get only Honeydew Mellons" goal, whatever the special fruit was.)
Some people will defend anything because it has the Nintendo name on it.